I'm not really sure what people expect from this event that makes them disspointed in the tea. My DW took our two boys on our first 7 day cruise in 2002, and they enjoyed it. Is it a high energy, multi-media presentation, nope. But they thought was cute and enjoyable.
We were also on the 9/25(27) cruise and chose to go agian, espcially since our God-daughter, her two sisters and mom were with us and had really wanted to do this. This time my youngest son (8) got picked to be one of Wendy's brothers. He thought that was cool, and we got some great photos. The girls enjoyed it and loved the chance to get photos and autographs.
Again, this is not a splashy event, but it is a cute, nice and fun moment on the ship.