I don't understand how the "open up to competitition" argument is supposed to work. I think the idea is that if everyone had completely free choice of what school they attended then the public schools would have to shape up in order to keep any students there because they'd all be swarming the private schools?
ETA: Just realized a poster above gave exactly this argument:
Not exactly true, either. In the special the head of NYC Catholic Schools discusses how children are not removed from their system. Instead they work with the kids. There is a vested interest in seeing these kids succeed. Afterall, if they don't succeed, why would other parents want to send their kids to that school?
Of course there is a very simple answer here. Open education to competition. Enough of the government held monopoly. The best schools will get the best students. The other schools will have to compete. They will have to prove thier worth to prospective students and parents. Bad schools will be closed. Good schools will get better. Good teachers will be paid more. Bad teachers will be paid less. There will be no "phoning it in." The special speaks about schools in Belgium. Any student can pick any school and the money follows the student, not the school. If a school doesn't perform the parent can yeank the kid. It's amazing how much more receptive teachers and administrators are when they know their job is on the line if the students aren't seeing value.
I find this idea very ironic given my own experiences in private vs. public school. Like most arguments about expanding the free market, the argument seems to assume that children/parents will act just like the theoretical beings of economics--always perfectly rationally calculating their self-interest and pursuing it. But if that were what people were like, wouldn't it already be the case that all private schools would be better than the public schools they compete with?

Because, if a private school weren't better than the public school next door, why would no rationally calculating self-interested parent/child would choose to pay money for something they could get for free--right?
Except, people do sent their children to private schools which are not as good as the public schools nearby. I know--my parents were those people (as well as most of the other parents who sent their kids to the Catholic School I attended from K-7th grade). It was quite clear that in every sense of *better* mentioned on this thread, the public school was better than the private (at least in middle school through high school, and I'm pretty sure earlier than that though I have less basis for comparison). There was much more tracking in the public school. Starting in middle school or earlier the public school had a gifted program and then began light tracking--below, average, above tracks. Meanwhile, at the Catholic School, the "gifted program" consisted of getting to use a computer (yeah, we never, ever got to have any of those in normal classes at Catholic school) once a week for weird computer programs like "test your spelling skills"

"Tracking" only started in middle school at the Catholic School, and it only applied to reading and math classes. It meant that above average folks in 7th grade, for instance, went to the 8th grade class for math and reading, below average folks went to the 6th grade class (bet that was good for the old self-esteem!), and average folks stayed in the 7th grade class. Even in the Catholic High School there were very few AP classes, and usually there were no more than 3 levels for any give course. By my senior in high school at the public school, we generally had about 6 different levels for any given course--from remedial, to below average, to average, to college prep, to honors, to AP. (I'm surprised, actually, that in this thread people have been complaining about the lack of tracking, because I thought all schools tracked. Everyone I have ever talked to about their high school experience was tracked in some way.)
As as I said, the Catholic School offered no access to computers except for those in the gifted program. Yet, just the next year when I switched to public school, we had a typing class in which each kid in the class had their own computer to work on. Class sizes were also larger at the Catholic School. It was a small school in which there was about 30 kids in each grade, and those 30 kids were your class all day long (except for reading and math). So every class you had had 30 kids in it. The Catholic School's attempt to include phys ed and the arts in the curriculum was completely sub-par compared to what was available at the public school.
As far as bad teachers, there were definitely many more in Catholic School than public school. And in Catholic Middle School, it's not like you only had to have each teacher for one class a day like in public school. Most of the time, you had one teacher who you had for almost every subject (except maybe math and science). When I was in 5th grade the teacher (I believe a nun maybe) who was teaching 7th grade had lost control of her students and so the school's solution was just to take the the 5th grade teacher and make her the 7th grade teacher (that is, interrupting the 5th graders in every single class in the middle of the year). The teacher who was moved from 5th to 7th grade seemed to have had a mid-life crisis (about then yes, she had a tiny little sports car and all) and was verbally abusive to one of the students she didn't like. She played favorites like I've never seen--I think she might have been in love with one of her favorites, she adored him so. Another time she got very angry when one girl was absent from school and a good friend of hers refused to announce
to the entire class what illness the girl had. (Turns out she was at the ER because she was constipated!

.) My 7th grade pre-algebra and reading teacher seemed to have no idea what teaching was about. She *literally* did not teach. I mean, instead of teaching, she'd have us play board games sometimes in reading class. We also had these two large assignments which consisted of getting into groups and coming up with a story of our own. Then we had to tape ourselves acting it out. Hey it was loads of fun, but how exactly was that helping with our reading skills? In math class she would generally just tell us to go ahead and work on some homework most of the time. I seriously think that she did not know how to do algebra, and that is why she didn't bother to teach. She would give us tests, though I don't know how anyone really passed them given she didn't teach us. I do know the guy next to me used to continually cheat off of me and a completely obvious way. I was a very meek and shy kid and I couldn't bring myself to say anything about it, so I just hoped she'd notice it, since it was so glaringly obvious! And she did notice it quite a few times; all she did was say "John Doe, eyes on your own paper" time and time again. I left pre-algebra not knowing the proper way to solve an equation like X - 12 = 5. I got it intuitively (just figure out what number, when you subtract 12 from it, gives you 5), but I didn't pick up the whole "whatever you do to one side of the equation you must do to the other" which is pretty much the fundamental rule of solving equations. My brother who was a bit younger than me had some behavior problems so my mother had to deal with each of the teachers views on punishment throughout his couple years. She felt the teachers and principles essentially simply decided that he was just a bad kid and would never be anything else. Anytime he was caught fighting or doing something bad with other kids, he was always assumed to be the ring leader and blamed for the whole thing. This is partly what soured my mother on the Catholic Church. (While he was no angel after he switched to public school, he did stop getting cast as the spawn of the devil and he stopped acting out so much.)
(This is not to say that every teacher in public school was great. But looking back, it is rather amazing that while in public school I had at least 6 teachers each year, and I can only remember one who I ever had a problem with. While in Catholic School I had more like 12 teachers tops for my whole 8 years and at least 3 there were big problems with.)
None of these things (except my brothers behavior stuff) actually seemed to bother my parents. I was getting good grades, and I had no behavior problems, so what was there to worry about? I'm not sure how much I told them about the game playing in reading class. I mean, why would we kids complain about that, it sure was better than actually learning! And I don't think my parents had any idea that what the Catholic School was offering academically was sub-par compared to the public school. I mean, how would they know? The reason they had chosen to pay for a Catholic School education is because 1) my dad had had a really bad experience in the public school in high school and I think he was still holding a grudge and 2) they really thought that a religious school would somehow be more comfortable and everyone would know each other and like each other and be nice to one another, and if there were problems the teachers would calmly sit down and talk about them with the parents and they'd come to an agreement together, etc. Apparently, this was also what had drawn many other parents to the school--some abstract quality (which had nothing to do with actual academic opportunities) of community or something.
In the end, my parents knew they had to switch us to public school because they couldn't afford the high school tuition--they were stretched way past their max just to pay the elementary and middle school tuition. They ended up switching us earlier than they had to, partly because they were fed up with the school's attitude toward my brother. I begged and cried and screamed for them to let me stay at least until the end of middle school. I thought they were the most horrible parents in the world. I was pretty shocked when I realized how much better public school was in almost every way. Now of course, you could say that moving my brother and moving me earlier than was financially necessitated was my parent's expressing their preferences in market decisions. But notice, for the first 8 years of my life they were not expressing their decisions well at all mostly because they did not have the necessary information (they didn't know how much better public school was) and they were influenced by some strange emotional/religious feeling. And I'm pretty sure that at times they were on the verge of not moving me because I was so upset about it.
This is why I don't understand talking about how market competition in schools would force them to improve. Wasn't the Catholic School under market pressure given there was a perfectly free alternative to it which was better in pretty much every way? So why didn't it improve?
