Starch Blockers...In the news last night

JessicaR

<font color=blue>DIS Veteran<br><font color=green>
Joined
Sep 26, 2000
Messages
15,730
This was on the 11'oclock news last night. I don't think I'll run out and get some but it will be interesting to see if this proves useful for some!



http://cbsnewyork.com
The Skinny On Starch Blockers
Nov 25, 2003 11:58 pm US/Eastern


Atkins, South Beach Diet, most of us are familiar with the trend in low carb diets. There's no question they take weight off, but keeping it off is tough.

Now comes a food supplement designed to prevent most carbohydrate calories from turning into fat. Can you have your pasta and eat it too? CBS 2's Paul Moniz reports.

They're called starch blockers; pills and gum-like chews that promise to stop starch calories from ending up on your waistline.

Dr. Jana Klauer is a weight loss specialist and says, "and what that does is block the breakdown of starch in the body so that the starch passes through so that you do not absorb the calories from the starch."

Is it possible to eat bread, potatoes, and pasta without absorbing the bulk of their starchy calories? Two small studies suggest starch blockers, containing a potent extract of white kidney beans, may be part of the solution.

Results from one company's literature promoting the pill "starch away" suggest it can block 2/3 of carbohydrate calories. Let's say you ate 2 slices of bread, instead of ingesting 136 starch calories you'd only absorb 46, a savings of 90 calories.

In a study sponsored by Starch Away, 60 men and women lost an average of a half-pound per week by taking one or two chews before each meal.

"Americans want to eat,” says Starch Away spokesman Suzy Cohen. “We don't want to be on a diet, and I think carb blockers offer American's a safe effective way to lose weight.”

Does this sound like a magic bullet for people? "There is no magic bullet, but if you want a safe and an effective way to lose weight, carb blockers are the way to go,” says Cohen. "These products don't jolt the heart, they don't raise blood pressure, they don't react with your other medication and they are free of serious side effects, you can't beat it."

But not everyone is buying into starch blocker claims. Specialists we spoke with say current research is preliminary and results from the ‘Starch Away’ study have not been peer reviewed.

"Whatever over the counter or dieter starch blockers there are, there is no evidence that those have any effect on body weight over the long term," says Dr. Stephen Heymsfield of St. Lukes Roosevelt.

The most common side effects of starch blockers are gastro-intestinal, associated with the bean extract.

“It could be gaseous, even diarrhea, cramping, could be a lot of discomfort,” says Sharon Movsas, a registered dietician.

Starch blockers may offer a glimmer of hope, but caution is advised. Proponents say they're useful as a weight loss tool, but critic’s point out they don't replace healthier eating and regular exercise.

They cost about $15-$45 for a one-month supply.
 
Hi,

Like you JessicaR, I don't think I'll run out and buy this. To me the best part of SBD is not having to purchase extra food or food supplements.

According to the article:
"They cost about $15-$45 for a one-month supply." That's $180-540 for the year, WOW!

Thanks for the article, I always like to see what's out there.

ADisneyMom
 
They said phen-fen was a great thing too.

I don't even like to take tylenol. There is no way on earth I would ever try anything like this.

When DH first went to the cardiologist, one of the first questions the Dr. asked was if he was taking any weight loss supplements. They must keep the cardiologists very busy.
 
It's a natural supplement, just extracted from white kidney beans. I had read about this in a health magazine and I do use them occassionaly if I feel I am getting too many starches in relation to the rest of the meal. I never had any side effects. I also sometimes use a fat blocker, not for weight reasons but because I have IBS and too much fat will set that off. And again that is a natural supplement.

These things are NOTHING like Phen-fen.
 

Interesting. We gave up refined carbohydrates because my dh is diabetic and I doubt this would help him. It might be useful to others, though.
 
I don't accept the argument that these are "natural" - heroin is a "natural" extract and so is sugar. I won't be using these.

However, there are others out there who desperately need to lose weight and if this is part of the solution for them, then great. I'd just rather eat meat and veggies and a very moderate amount of good carbs (in foods that give me a lot of nutritional value for the amount of carbs they contain).

If these products block the carbs, do they also block the absorption of nutrients? I'd be afraid that any vitamins and minerals contained in the meal would be flushed out of the body also, instead of getting absorbed.
 
Originally posted by DoeWDW
If these products block the carbs, do they also block the absorption of nutrients? I'd be afraid that any vitamins and minerals contained in the meal would be flushed out of the body also, instead of getting absorbed.

That is an excellent question. I think this post is interesting in the responses given. I seems as though we are a group of losing it the "natural" way bunch. No magic pills for us. It does sound tempting though. Not for me of course, but DH who has T2 diabetes. He'll never do it though. I've been getting on him to try low carb, but he is still with the prevailing low fat regime. He says he may try Atkins like program if he could be more active, but right now with all the travel between time zones' he's either working or sleeping.:( Thanks for the post.

Keep the Faith!
Tracy
 
Like I said I only use it on occassion, and honestly I don't notice a difference. My jar has been hanging around for over three months now. So that tell you something.

Yep there is no magic pill. It just seems to help sometimes with some of my other problems. :D If it keeps me from doing something destructive then I don't know what the big deal is about something that comes from a BEAN. :p
 
You're right, Miss Jasmine. It sounds perfectly harmless.

I was a bit overzealous above, but my point was that I don't like to take anything, be it medicine, herbal or otherwise. I don't evaluate products on a case by case basis. I just choose not to use any unless it is medically necessary and I still don't like it then. ;)

If others choose to use it, I hope it works wonders for them.
 
Hi,

I'm with LisaTx, I have a hard time taking things.

In fact I'm getting ready to get on a heavy duty iron program because I'm so anemic. I don't like to take anything not even iron pills but if I don't I think my doctor might try to force me somehow. Anyway I did sign up to get healthy so I'm going to do it.


I also agree with LisaTx that if it is something you need and it helps then go for it.


ADisneyMom
 
Miss Jasmine, I didn't mean to sound so negative in my previous post. If it's working for you on an occasional basis, then why not use it? I'm like the other posters - I hate to take anything. :D
 
Let's just say Vitamin World likes me. ;) But I am not crazy about prescriptions and OTC medicines. :p
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter
Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom