We ate there on our first night in WDW...
I didn't know what to expect, but we both thought it was very good.
I had the fettucini alfredo and DH had spaghetti and marinara. We also ordered the three cheese foccacia and they also brought out some bread and dipping oil.
The sangria was VERY good!
Personally, we don't typically like italian food (too heavy), but Spoodles was very good. I know they have more "Mediteranean" (sp?) fare, I kind of thought of Spoodles as a pumped up, much better version of Olive Garden...
I think you should try it once...the prices are reasonable, and the food is good, our server was wonderful...at least you can say you've tried it and then know if you don't want to go there again.