We have eaten at Spoodles every single trip since they opened .. sometimes 2 or 3 times (counting breakfast). We love it! The 4 cheese flatbread is my favorite dish at WDW.
Here is the review my DD24 wrote from a trip last year. It is too bad they have changed the pasta dish, but this may give you an idea.
Dinner Spoodles, The Boardwalk
Our PS for Spoodles was for 7:15, and we were right on time. They told us it would be a 10 minute wait for our table, but it was more like 2. Wed no more than sat down when the beeper started beeping. Cant beat that!
Our table was at the front of the restaurant near the windows, so for Spoodles it was actually not all that loud. Wow, amazing. Mom got the Spoodlerita, which she usually does, and she said it was wonderful as always. We ordered the 4-cheese flat bread for appetizer, and it was yummy as always. Lots o garlic to keep the vampires at bay! Our waitress, though, brought the bread and the flatbread at the same time, and I wish she hadnt done that, b/c theyve changed the bread! Instead of the hummus spread like they used to have, they now have an olive oil and spices dip. Its sooo yummy! Its like the stuff they make for you at a lot of Italian restaurants, only 500 times better! Its got parmesan, garlic, red pepper, chili flakes
Im not even sure what all!
Anyway, for our main course we both got the alfredo pasta, but I got mine w/ chicken. I wished I hadnt, though, b/c it didnt add much flavor and just made it heavier. The dish was wonderful on its own and didnt need the chicken; the sauce was just right, not too heavy, and the prosciutto added a nice saltiness.
For dessert we got the sampler platter to split. It had pistachio mousse (Moms favorite); baklava (neither of us are really crazy about that, but it was ok); cheesecake (so yummy!!); an orange cake something (ok, I cant remember the name, but it was my favorite and SO GOOD!); and the flourless chocolate cake (always delicious). It was certainly decadent, and definitely a good choice if you cant decide what to choose!