We went to both Hoop De Doo and Spirit of Aloha this December. I have been to Hoop Dee Doo about 5 times. First time going to Aloha.
The food at Hoop De Doo was terrible. Might have been an off night for the Hoop De do, I have never had food this bad there. The potatoes were watery and the ribs and chicken were dry. Everything else was good. Probably the worst meal we had all trip. Not sure what was going on that night. the show was enjoyable as always.
After sitting through the first 10 minutes of Spirit of Aloha I was about ready to leave, but the food was excellent (the desert was kind of uninspired, they should probably change it). After dinner the show changed into something great. Not just the fire dance either, all the dancing was great. Before/during dinner the show is a 1, after dinner I would give it a 10. Of course, if you don't like dancing you would probably hate the entire thing except the fire dance. They really need to revamp this show, axing the entire first half would be a good start.