If you read my post, you would know that I said that a zoom comes in handy for animals. For anything else that isn't spooked its just as easy to simply walk closer. I'll take the time to walk closer to what I'm shooting any day over using a zoom.... and usually that's possible except with things like animals.
And yes, I've never heard of a Samyang... but I also simply suggested getting the set and then selling that lens and the camers... while Quantaray lenses aren't top of the line lenses I would put them in the same tier as other third parties like Sigma... The OP is clearly on a budget so going out and getting Zeiss glass isn't a likely option... so if your going to go for off brand why not get reasonably priced off-brand. If they think they like a big zoom they can always make a quality zoom purchase later in life.
I did read your post, and I respectfully disagreed, so there really is no need to get defensive.
walking closer works in some cases, but not all, and animals are not the exception...
the minute you walk closer to children, you've lost the moment, walking closer to children on a sports field, not doable..walking closer to floats in the main st parade to get good shots of individual characters..not doable.. walking closer to get good individual shots of characters on stage at WDW not doable..shooting people or models, a good fast zoom gives the best selective focus without getting too close to the subject and making them uncomfortable..
this is what a good zoom allows you to do at wdw..
on this trip I was using 2 bodies, my 35-105, and my 100-300
this combination or my 28-300 gives the versatility to shoot an entire float, then quickly zoom for a head shot..,
my point was and is... that for your type of shooting zooms may be over rated, but for many other people they are a neccessity..
having sold cameras for 3 years, I would never put the quantary lenses on the same level, as other 3rd party lenses even though they were supposedly made by sigma.. the pictures I saw coming thru our lab, just indicated differently.
Zeiss glass was never mentioned, neither were Minolta g lenses, so that is irrelevent..
the other inherent problem with buying a maxxum 7000 package to get a used minolta lens, is that you stand a good chance of getting an original series maxxum lens. the I series and later lenses are much faster autofocusing and quieter..