Solid surface countertops, $$?

Jenny3

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jun 13, 2011
Messages
636
Hi there,

We are renovating our kitchen this summer and have decided on some type of solid surface countertop. Just not sure what kind yet!

If you have these, can you share what kind (granite, corian, etc) and anything you like or dislike? Also a rough idea of cost would be very helpful!!

TIA!!
 
I have quartz (manfuctured but 90% stone), had it 7 years now, bought from Lowes, about $3000 installed at the time, large L shaped counter, but I don't have the measurements. I love that I never have to worry about heat/hot pads, and that clean up is a cinch. I also love/hate the fact that because of the speckled pattern I chose, I sometimes, can't tell its dirty without running my hands over it LOL.
 
I also have quartz (silestone) and absolutely love it! No worries about sealing it or placing a hot dish on it.
 

We have Corian. I was planning on getting one of the nicer granite-look laminates when we redid our kitchen, but there was a fabulous deal on about 25 Corian patterns at my kitchen place, where the Corian with an integral sink installed was the same price as the laminate uninstalled.

I'd never thought much of Corian, thought it would be too plasticky but I like it a lot. It looks great and it's much warmer than expected. The integral sink is awesome to keep clean.

What I would love is granite but it wasn't in the budget. I like natural materials and would love a granite with some movement.
 
Quartz in my main house and I love it! We have granite in 2nd home and I hate it
 
We LOOOVE the granite in our kitchen. It's so unusual - black with big blotches of white. Some parts you can look through the granite - kind of hard to explain - like 3d for countertops! I don't remember how much it cost, but it was worth it! I love that I can take things out of the oven/off of the stove and put them right on it without worries. It does require a special "sealing" coat once a year (not a big deal - DH does it), and we do use granite cleaner to clean it.

We are remodeling our girls' bathroom and chose silestone (sp?) for that. It costs about the same price as granite, but it's lower maintenance.
 
I have quartz (manfuctured but 90% stone), had it 7 years now, bought from Lowes, about $3000 installed at the time, large L shaped counter, but I don't have the measurements. I love that I never have to worry about heat/hot pads, and that clean up is a cinch. I also love/hate the fact that because of the speckled pattern I chose, I sometimes, can't tell its dirty without running my hands over it LOL.

Same here! We put our quartz in this past summer. We have a small kitchen but with a large overhang so it added a bit of cost. We paid $5000 for the countertop, installation and sink. We took out the old counter top (they hauled it away) and installed the faucet and disposal ourselves. Saved us about $600.

Our quartz is by Cambria which is a company in PA and the quartz is made in the USA. We loved that fact.
 
Also wanted to add that I thought I wanted Granite, but my sister bless her heart, big HGTV fan that she is, said no you want Quartz, and I had never even heard of it. Like the above poster mentioned, the edging your choose can have a big effect on the price. I choose the round front edge (bull nose I think) and didn't add the back splash, as I intended to do custom tile for the back splash, we also did our own removal, and kept the existing sink which was in good shape. All those things will affect your price.
 
We have quartz (silestone) in the kitchen, love it!! No staining, hot pads, easy cleaning except you can't always tell it is dirty. (This is not a bad thing in my opinion, either!) I have a small granite top in the master bath, which is 1 year old. I hate it! Water splashing has stained & changed the color of the stone. Under the soap dispenser is another rind of discoloration. It was sealed & this still occurred. I may be the only one that notices that the sand color granite has an orange tint & dark spots, but it does bother me. I wouldn't have purchased granite over silestone, but it was only offering from the tub place.
 
I have Quartz. I chose that over granite as it never needs resealing and I prefer a uniform pattern. If you want something unique, with veins, granite would be a better choice. The price is very comparable with QUartz being slightly more expensive. Also with granite you need to make sure anything acidic isn't left on it (lemon juice etc).

I had 37sq feet, with a designer edge and I paid ~$4K, taxes in.

I truly dislike the look of Corian.
 
Glad to hear all the great quartz reviews! We're looking at taking out our laminate counter tops sometime soon and are leaning toward quartz. :goodvibes Thought about Corian but my MIL got Corian counter tops a few years back and HATES them. She thinks they scratch too easily. :confused3
 
I have quartz (Zodiaq) in the kitchen and love it for its low maintenance.

My friend's Corian got ruined when her MIL (who has granite counters) put a hot casserole dish directly on it. The damage was too much to just be sanded out. Boy was she mad, because they had just remodeled that kitchen.

One thing about quartz is that despite its speckled appearance, it really looks "frozen" compared to granite which often has direction or movement in it, so that is entirely a personal aesthetic decision.

There's a huge range in price for granite, there's colors considered lower grade (and even that varies depending on who you buy the granite from) to more pricey and exotic granites. If you go the granite route, I'd for sure go personally to pick out your slab. Other people's version of "oh, that little blemish is no big deal, it's fine" may not be the same as yours.

Through big box stores or well-known countertop businesses around here I'd see prices on the order of $60/sf installed for quartz and granite and it goes up (~$120/sf depending on the grade) from there. You get dinged for sink cut-outs (often $100-$200), sometimes faucet cut-outs, and your edge treatment (usually there are 1-3 edge treatments included with the basic cost) so be sure to ask the cost of those because it adds up. One thing to realize is that the actual cutting and polishing is done by a fabricator and it's they who tell the retailers what they charge for these "extras."

Now, sinks -- you should buy your own rather than go with whatever the countertop people say they have because almost inevitably you can get the same thing on eBay or Amazon for a LOT less, almost 50% less (and you will faint when you see the cost of some of these sinks and the faucets). But get the brand and model# they are offering so you can do an apples to apples comparison (just say you want to look it up to see what it looks like).

A kitchen remodel will take up more of your mental energy and time than you would ever think. I spent hours on the kitchen forum at gardenweb, trying to make sure I thought of everything...and there are still some things I didn't think of and realized after my kitchen was done. The #1 mess-up is that the underside of my countertop that sits on a raised bar didn't get polished, so every time I sit in my family room and look toward the kitchen I can see the rough ugly surface. I just never even thought that that was something I had to ask for! Grr.

That said, have fun with your kitchen remodel! It will be a worthwhile project.
 
I have Corian with an integral sink. It is great because their are no seams to clean and I put hot stuff on it all the time.
 
I've had my Corian for four years now and have had no problem with scratching. I do not put hot pots on it and I don't cut directly on it. I had laminate before, and I didn't do those things with laminate, so it's not a problem for me.

The appeal of quartz I just don't get, although I know it's very trendy now. To me, it's nowhere near as attractive as granite and it's more expensive. I've got granite in my bathroom and the amount of effort required to seal it is nothing. I think it's funny that people make a big deal over that.

For cost and feature comparisons, see http://www.oneprojectcloser.com/kitchen-countertop-material-comparison/
 
Something important about Corian- it is a 1/2" sheet of plastic. (The plastic is referred to as solid surface, and Corian is a specific brand) If they do not mount that solid surface sheet correctly to the substrate (usually just plywood) or don't continuously mount it it can and does crack from heat. Usually the front edge is built up so people think it is an inch or two thick- it's not.

Buying Corian directly from the manufacturer's rep is anywhere from $25-55 per square foot so the color you pick can make a big difference in how expensive it is. Different brands usually run a little less because the Dupont name is better known. They make a quartz composite as well called Zodiac, essentially the look of solid surface made of natural materials and less likely to crack/chip/stain.

I would go with a stone if you don't want to have to worry about manufacturing or how they are going to prepare the material.
 
We wanted a modern look and went with concrete. I think it looks awesome.
 













Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE














DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top