Should kids from minivan plunge be buried with their mother?

Should these children be buried with their mother?

  • Yes

  • No

  • That's a tough one, I can't decide

  • Other


Results are only viewable after voting.
Not sure if this is known but the surviving sons father is in prison. The kid is ten, years of therapy ahead of him. I think it's proper to bury them separately because he will surely want to visit his half siblings and not the woman killed them and tried to kill him.

Also, if my husband cheated or was abusive there is no way my rational brain would choose suicide/ murder. Maybe cut his butt up but not killing myself let alone my child. I'm sorry for this family. This woman clearly needed mental intervention. The dad did the right thing. There will be many who will want to pay respect to the children but not the mother and this will make it easier for them. Thinking about the survivor, I doubt he will want to go to the funeral of the person who killed his siblings and tried to kill him. This is the best choice because it doesn't pressure him. The years of therapy this child will need will hopefully help him get through this. I feel awful for all parties.
 
I picked Other because I don't know how it's any of my business.

Also, if it were me, the'd all be cremated. And I probably would be in an psyche ward somewhere. :confused3
 
I picked Other because I don't know how it's any of my business.Also, if it were me, the'd all be cremated. And I probably would be in an psyche ward somewhere. :confused3

It is a discussion board. We discuss things that aren't our business all the time. :thumbsup2
 
"I'll come to his little cheesy services," Gilliam said, adding that Pierre had chosen "some little, low-budget, welfare kind of cemetery" for the children's final resting place.

This made my stomach turn and speaks volumes of this family.:sad2: He is the father it's his choice.
 
This made my stomach turn and speaks volumes of this family.:sad2: He is the father it's his choice.

Not to mention, lord knows what the funeral/burial costs are for THREE children and that sorry excuse for a mother. I don't think this family is exactly rolling in dough and I doubt they had insurance on the kids. Coming up with the money for all these expenses is likely beyond his means. And if the funeral home or some donor "helped" with expenses, it's not going to be a luxury funeral.
 
While this guy was not a gem of anything, there is still no excuse for murdering your kids. Sorry.....


The boyfriend of a woman who killed herself and their three kids was pounding on her apartment door in a rage for 30 minutes before she drove the family van into the Hudson River.

Neighbor Latoya James told the Daily News that the angry confrontation started around 6:30 p.m. Tuesday, when Jean Pierre - in apparent violation of an order of protection - arrived at the Newburgh residence.

"The dad was banging on the door real loud," James said Friday. "He called to her, 'Open the f------ door!' He was there about a half an hour - he was on the phone as well."

The dispute ended with a tender moment between Jean Pierre and 10-year-old Lashaun Armstrong, the lone survivor after his mother drowned herself and his three siblings in the brackish water.

"He came down and opened the door ... He said, 'Daddy, I love you,'" recalled James, 30. "He said, 'I love you too, man,' and kissed him on the forehead."

About 15 minutes later, James watched Lashanda Armstrong load her four children into the van and drive off - a six-block ride that ended with all but Lashaun dead inside the vehicle.

The relationship between Pierre, 26, girlfriend Armstrong and their three children was often combative, with many fights sparked by his infidelities, neighbors said.

An April 12 order of protection forced Pierre to avoid contact with his 2-year-old son, Lance.

Pierre was arrested after the tot was found at 1:15 a.m. on Feb. 7, wandering barefoot and half-naked through the snow, police said.

A neighbor called cops to the scene and authorities later said he claimed that he had walked to a nearby gas station in the early morning hours after Super Bowl Sunday.

"(Lance) kept saying, 'Where's my daddy?' " neighbor Mike Lawrence, 26, recalled of the tot. "He was mostly naked, with his pants down around his ankles in the snow.

"The father came back and asked who had his son," Lawrence continued. "He was with this woman."

http://articles.nydailynews.com/2011-04-15/news/29452984_1_family-van-order-kids
 
I don't think anyone is saying that the man would win the Father of the Year award, but the mother killed the children.

I can't imagine being so angry at my spouse/partner that I would kill my children. Kill him? Maybe ;). But my kids...nope.
 
They are gone. I don't think it matters where they are buried. It's rare that anyone in my family is buried. The whole burial thing is weird as far as I'm concerned. I think it's been turned into something spiritual when it was originally done to prevent disease. I know, it's just my opinion and I accept that. I can't personally understand her actions. I also have never been severely abused.
 
It is a discussion board. We discuss things that aren't our business all the time. :thumbsup2

OK, then. I picked other. If I was in jail, and my wife killed herself and my children, I would have them all cremated.

And then I'd hang myself.
 
She murdered her kids in cold blood. I can't say I blame him for burying her separate from them. It sounds like a normal emotional response to the tragedy.

Now the son that survived and the dad can visit the cemetery without bumping into the other family. Seems reasonable to me.

I understand that the family of the mother are mad but they have to accept that what she did to her children has no excuses.

It is one thing to off yourself. It is another to kill children.

While I agree that they are angry, hurt and what she did was inexcusable, I still think he should have buried them together.

I do believe him when he says he loved her very much, and I am sure they had a lot of good times and great memories. In time (probably many years down the road) he will probably be able to forgive her, and may feel differently about his decision.

I also believe it would be great for his surviving son to learn to forgive and move on. This is going to be horrible for him, but it will be much worse if he has to live with a father who is harboring resentment and unable to forgive his dead mother.
 
While I agree that they are angry, hurt and what she did was inexcusable, I still think he should have buried them together.

I do believe him when he says he loved her very much, and I am sure they had a lot of good times and great memories. In time (probably many years down the road) he will probably be able to forgive her, and may feel differently about his decision.

I also believe it would be great for his surviving son to learn to forgive and move on. This is going to be horrible for him, but it will be much worse if he has to live with a father who is harboring resentment and unable to forgive his dead mother.

I don't think he is the father of the surviving 10 year old child. He is the father of the three younger children who drowned. The oldest child actually escaped from the sinking car and a passing motorist found him dripping wet on the side of the road. How horrific for that child. :sad2:

I feel the father has the right to decide where to bury the children.
 
Op here. This caught my attention because I know a family in which something similar happened and the family chose to bury them all together. I remember at the time on hearing that being a little shocked but then again it wasn't ever anything I'd ever thought about and I realized I wouldn't know what I'd do if I were (God forbid) ever faced with a similar decision.

Everyone's mentioned the father and the mother, but my thoughts keep going to the surviving son. (I wondered if Mr. Pierre was his father, thanks Princess for clarfiying he was not - but it makes it even more difficult, I think.) Does he hate his mother for what she did? Or does he still love and miss his Mommy? Is his allegiance going to be further divided (mother, siblings, step dad, bio dad, aunt) by having those he loved buried separately? I don't know. But it's what's in my head. Clearly there are no right or wrong answers here.

I agree with Fire Dancer and others, though. If anyone harmed my kids, becoming fish food would probably be too good for them so I can understand the father's decision, for sure.
 
We had a case up here in NY about a month ago where the husband beat his wife to death then hanged himself. The five kids insisted they have a joint funeral and be buried together. :confused3 The kids ranged from the teens to 20's. The wife had moved out prior to her murder.
 
This happened just across the river from me, and it just breaks my heart to even think about it. Reading what that boy had told the woman who picked him up brought tears to me eyes, I don't think he will ever be able to come to terms with what happened. She took him into the backseat with her, and told him if she was going to die, that they were going to die with her. She doesn't deserve to be anywhere near those kids after what she's done. She doesn't deserve his forgiveness either.
 
He wouldn't HAVE to bury the children at all if it weren't for the mother. I don't give a rat's hiney what the issues were between the parents, you DO NOT kill your kids. Off yourself, but not your kids. :headache:

This.

I also believe it would be great for his surviving son to learn to forgive and move on. This is going to be horrible for him, but it will be much worse if he has to live with a father who is harboring resentment and unable to forgive his dead mother.

You know, there are a LOT of times that I think all this "forgive and move on" stuff is just a bunch of bull. How much therapy is needed to convince a person to forgive his own mother for killing herself and murdering his siblings? Maybe I'm not a very forgiving person, but I don't think I could forgive someone for doing something like that, even if they were mentally ill. :sad2:That poor child!!
 
No they should be buried seperately. If they were buried with their mother this poor man will have to visit his childrens' graves next to the woman that murdered them. That seems cruel to me. Let him bury them whereever he wants.

Yup.
 
While I agree that they are angry, hurt and what she did was inexcusable, I still think he should have buried them together.

I do believe him when he says he loved her very much, and I am sure they had a lot of good times and great memories. In time (probably many years down the road) he will probably be able to forgive her, and may feel differently about his decision.

I also believe it would be great for his surviving son to learn to forgive and move on. This is going to be horrible for him, but it will be much worse if he has to live with a father who is harboring resentment and unable to forgive his dead mother.

Maybe burying them separately is the way that they are able to forgive and move on?
 
You know, there are a LOT of times that I think all this "forgive and move on" stuff is just a bunch of bull. How much therapy is needed to convince a person to forgive his own mother for killing herself and murdering his siblings? Maybe I'm not a very forgiving person, but I don't think I could forgive someone for doing something like that, even if they were mentally ill. :sad2:That poor child!!
You are under the mistaken belief that forgiving someone means you're giving them something. Wrong. You're giving yourself something when you forgive someone else:

internal peace.

Forgiving someone doesn't mean you're approving of what they did. It just means that it's in the past and you can't change it. To not forgive someone doesn't hurt them; it hurts you.
 
If my DH murdered our children, I would not allow them to be buried anywhere near him.

ETA - I can forgive a lot of things. I could not forgive my spouse for murdering our children. No way, no how.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom