I can understand why you were disappointed np4gp, that does not sound like a great view at all.
I am not sure why exactly I think Kidani is my most favorite DVC, and to be honest, I have not come close to trying them all so who knows?. It may be a culmination of very positive staff experiences, along with phenominal bus transportation, beautiful room, fantastic meals, and a great view.
I think it might also be the subtle atmosphere of Kidani. I have heard people mention how calm and quiet Kidani is, and I did not think of this as a real asset. Maybe because its a sorta 'standalone' DVC property, with its own check in area, it feels a lot less like a hotel, and a lot more like a vacation home. Not millions of people checking in, and rushing around, like at the BC. (Although I enjoy the fun atmosphere of busy beach club, I think I prefer the calm and relaxing atmosphere of Kidani after being in the parks)
At Jambo house, I fell like I am in a beautiful hotel, the lobby is inspiring, but it has that same sense of rush/urgency as the BCV, imo. The smaller, quieter Kidani is my preference, it is still OMG beautiful lobby, just on a smaller scale.
Disclaimer- I nevr have stayed at Jambo, so I cant give opinions on how it truly compares with Kidani. I think if we stayed longer then a week at Kidani, I wonder if not have a convienent food court location might end up being a pain in the butt. As it was, we stayed 4 days Kidani, and brought breakfast items for the morning, lunched in the parks, and then did dinners on site (or at the park). The Kidani/beach club split was a nice combo, sortof a best of both worlds. At Kidani, we did the AK, BB and MK. The transportation was phenominal. At BCV we did Epcot and Studios.
I will say, that to me, hands down, I would pick Kidani over beach club. I know lots of people would disagree, and thats ok! I think there is an old indian saying that goes something like this - if everyone liked the same thing, everyone would want my squaw!
Maybe because I felt like I could truly relax and unwind when we got back to Kidani after the parks made it feel more like a vacation, and not go-go-go. I also think I had better try OKW, because it may appeal to me as well.
I guess I am going to have to do an add on!