~Awww, was I too hard on Mr. Pirate? Maybe. But, why say things like "nothing is free" while indulging in "free beer" elsewhere. I just *love* that grumpy pirate

-- but you can't have it both ways, right??? You can't blame people for getting hooked on "
free dining" -- just like you can't blame people for indulging in "free beer" -- the drawbacks from any promotion lies with the company, so let's direct most of the blame there --that's all I'm saying.
~I'm not a fan of "free dining" -- I've seen it bring out the worst on both sides. With that said, I loved the first dining plan, now it's just okay -- the value aspect for me has diminished tremendously -- now, it's just a matter of convenience.
~I know you don't like the dining plan but it was necessary for Disney to intervene because the resale of vouchers on ebay had gotten out of hand. An individual could get up to thirty meal vouchers from hotwire.com for 7 -10 bucks per voucher (each voucher including an appetizer, full entree, drink, dessert and gratuity) and people were reselling them for 3 or 4 times that.
~So, when Disney introduced the dining plan, this immediately terminated the voucher program. Most people weren't even aware of the dining plan until the free dining promotion -- as it became wildly popular, that's when we started to experience the significant decline in dining for a brief period.