We do have Good Friday off. My dd, 10, came home yesterday and told me that there was no homework given due to Passover!! Now, I figure that it's either a holiday or it isn't. Some schools in my area have Friday off, some don't. I agree that it should be up to the family to decide. I know a lot of my dd's friends are Jewish and they travel at this time. So, they are not in school. Maybe school systems could just have, say, 5 days total for the year that would be discretionary so that families could celebrate the religious holidays they choose. I do think that Christmas would have to be a part of the 'winter break' tho. There are just too many out there that would never work on that day!!!