School board question......

McKelly

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jan 22, 2004
Messages
4,266
Over 1/2 of our public school board sends their children to private schools. I am not sure how I feel about that. I kind of feel like, who are you to tell me what is good for my kids? ...the public schools are good enough for my kids, but not for yours? Just wondering how other people feel about it.
 
It wouldn't bother me at all. Who knows the reason why they send their kids to private school. Religous reasons? Academic? Closer to home? Social issues? There can be a bunch of reasons. And it wouldn't matter to me why. Just because they don't send their kids to public school doesn't mean they don't know how to be a board member and do the right thing.
 
Personally, I have never voted for someone to join our school board unless they sent their children to public schools. Most in our area have kids well out of school...
 
That would bother me. I think that you see much more by having a child in the schools (or working in them).
 

I would have a hard time trusting someone to make decisions about my child's education when they don't see the schools as being right for their children.
 
We have a member of our school board who homeschools. I did not vote for this person and I can't believe that others did. The issue in our district is the board was asking for an increase in taxes to pay for new construction. Then the real estate downturn happened and the number of students in the district didn't go up as fast as the previous board predicted. So, he campaigned on the premise that the previous board wasn't fiscally responsible, and everyone who didn't have a child in the public schools voted for him. In the meantime, those of us who do have children in the public schools are glad that we have enough classrooms now that we aren't cramming 35 kids in a single classroom!
 
It really bothers me when a school board member doesn't have a child in a public school. The problems are only really felt from inside the system. Private schools are run very differently, and not always "better", they have their own problem. So, no, I won't vote for any Board member who didn't have a child who didn't attend a public school or work at one. Now, if they don't have any kids, but have some skill that can be used on the Board, then I would consider them.
 
That would bother me a little. IMO board members with kids in the district or with kids who attended the district are sometimes more inclined to do what is educationally right for the district.

In our district we get a lot of school board candidates whose sole purpose of running is in the interest of keeping school taxes low. Now, there's nothing wrong with wanting to keep taxes low but IMHO the first priority should be to provide the kids in the district the best education possible.
 
Thanks for the replies. It appears I am not alone in those feelings then. Some very important school board elections are coming soon and I am just trying to make the best decision I can for my kids. I appreciate those who weighed in.
 
I wouldn't vote for them.

I also don't particularly care for it when former teachers or administrators are on the board. I used to think it made sense until I saw some of the things they bring to the table -- things that would benefit their friends in the schools.
 
I would rather the school board have kids that are in or have been through our schools. How about this? When I was about 20, I went out on a few dates with a guy who was a few years older than me and I found out he was on the PTA board for his local school. He didn't have kids and I thought that was weird. :confused3
 
I would rather the school board have kids that are in or have been through our schools. How about this? When I was about 20, I went out on a few dates with a guy who was a few years older than me and I found out he was on the PTA board for his local school. He didn't have kids and I thought that was weird. :confused3

Some people choose to not have kids or can't have kids and want to be involved. So I wouldn't think it was weird.
 
It wouldn't bother me at all if the school board member had NO children, but I wouldn't vote for someone who chose to send their children to private school --it does seem elitist, as if they want to tell "the little people" how to do things, while they go do their own thing. I'd wonder WHY they wanted to be involved in public schools if they didn't want their children in them.

However, I can tella similar story that doesn't have any strange underlying motives:

I used to send my children to private school when they were in the lower grades, but I've always taught at a public high school. Why'd I do this? Simple: I wanted them to start out in a Christian environment, and I knew that the school they were attending had a solid phonics-based reading program, while the public schools were using a combination of sight-words and holistic reading. I wanted them to have that solid start. Also, originally there was a very practical reason: We could have the oldest attending kindergarten on one end of the building while the youngest went to day care on the other end. It made drop offs and pick ups much easier, and that was worth a great deal to us.

BUT I always intended that they'd transfer to public school well before high school -- before they reached my school. I wanted them to have the benefits of more honors classes, more languages, a more diverse student body, more clubs, more travel opportunities . . . and that's exactly what we've done.

I think we've given our children the best of both worlds by handling it this way. But that's not really the same thing as the school board situation.
 
Yep -- I'd have a big problem with it, too. I don't want a parent making educational decisions for my child, when her education decision for her child was to send her to private school!
 
Some people choose to not have kids or can't have kids and want to be involved. So I wouldn't think it was weird.

Now I get it but when I was 20 and nowhere near having kids I thought it was strange.
 
That would make me wonder. While I understand everyone has their reasons for whatever school they choose, I'd feel better knowing that my school board members have as vested an interest in the public schools as I do. If they are there to simply keep taxes down or to get something that only benefits their child, I wouldn't be happy.

My advice is to look at these people's records. Our current school board has a few people whose children graduated years ago. As long as they're as dedicated to a great education as they were when their kids were in school, I'm good with that.

I also think that if I chose private schools for my kids, I'd probably be more involved with their schools than the public ones. Who knows, maybe they are.
 
Yeah that would really bother me.

Sorta OT but a good story none the less....

When I was in Kindergarten we lived in a very small town (6 kids in the entire kindergarten). There was a boy that was our age that lived a few houses away but none of us were allowed to play with him, his mothers decision. This little boy went to private school and was not allowed to play with kids that went to public school.


Wait for it....





His mother turned out to be my 8th grade science teacher - in PUBLIC SCHOOL!!!!
 
Yes, I would have a problem with it. I am also seeing the damage caused by a school board with the majority of its members being former educators. The kids lose out while the teachers win. Before you bash me as a teacher hater, that is so not the case, but we have so many policies that other schools around us don't have that have really hurt our kids.
 
Yes, I would have a problem with it. I am also seeing the damage caused by a school board with the majority of its members being former educators. The kids lose out while the teachers win. Before you bash me as a teacher hater, that is so not the case, but we have so many policies that other schools around us don't have that have really hurt our kids.

I believe you...and my DH is a teacher. Our current board now has four teachers. While it's nice to have members with these backgrounds, I do worry from the fiscal side.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom