We've done the Regal Eagle package for the Broadway shows during FotA and for Eat to the Beat just last week. For those shows, we were able to arrive around noon and still get our choice of shows. As PP noted, if you are trying for a show with a very, popular narrator, I would prepare to be at the restaurant at opening or shortly before to get one of the shows (you may want to have a first, second and third choice if your preferred time sells out). As PP noted, you will order your meal when you arrive, so make sure you are hungry. I love the Regal Eagle package - it's the most cost effective way to get preferred seating and I think the food is very good. Depending on what you order (higher priced entree, for instance), it's a pretty good deal, IMHO. The preferred seating is so good.