Wow, thanks for the feedback, guys! Let me catch up:
I think Only the Lonely DID kill the other rooster. I've seen them fight before.
Re: finding a farmer ... I've asked around at the farmer's market and asked many of the farming/chicken-keeping customers at my workplace, but haven't found any takers. I didn't think asking if I could borrow a cage, but perhaps if I could, animal control would be willing to take it then. Thanks for the tip!
Re: animal rescues, I called all of them that I could find but didn't find any that would take chickens, but that's been a while, so there could be a new one I'm not aware of, so I'll check! Thanks!
@Scurvy, my husband used a soft pellet gun at my suggestion, and it didn't do any good--they didn't even flinch. He then borrowed a BB gun from a coworker and shot at the bird from a rather long range (he didn't want to break skin on it), and after several shots got the chickens to run down the road, but they came back after a few days, and we didn't think it was the greatest idea to keep shooting them all the time. Believe it or not, I am a sappy animal lover. That's why we're still having this problem. I never thought of a super soaker ... that wouldn't hurt him but should really annoy him!
@Disfan, I didn't even think of FFA--great tip!
@Imzadi, I may have to buy a pack-and-play and try this. The past two nights I've ended up sitting on the couch with her asleep in my arms after hours of her crying. She's almost two, and our living room is connected to the kitchen so I never leave her in the living room by herself, but if I had a pack-and-play that she couldn't climb out of (she's in a toddler bed now), that might be an option. Our apartment is rather small for three people, but I'll bet I could make it work if I need to. Thanks!
To everyone re: animal cruelty, I really don't want any harm to have to come to this rooster, but I can't say I feel that way every morning for hours when my daughter is screaming because Only the Lonely won't shut up. Lack of sleep does nasty, terrible things to a child. I've been very conflicted because I love animals, but I have never felt so much contempt for an animal before. I got more sleep in the first couple weeks of motherhood than I'm getting now.
Speaking of which, she cried all afternoon from being tired and having a headache ... so at the peak of her shrieking, I took her down to the apartment office, sat her on the manager's desk and said "Let's talk about the rooster that keeps my daughter up all night." I know that's manipulative, but she did promise to make some calls about how to capture the chicken and what to do with it--and she seemed sincere. So, fingers crossed!
Thanks to everyone for feedback ... I'm definitely taking this advice to heart to try and get the situation resolved.
