This is a great question, as it seems EVERYONE gets every request while I never get anything!!! How many posts have I read of everyone getting Building 14 at POR or Cabana 9 at CSR? As for me, I have accepted I will always be in the boonies or in the last desirable location anywhere I stay! I know when I pay for standard view I should expect standard view, but some standards are worse than others!
Some examples:
Twice at POR, I made a request for Alligator Bayou, as I stayed in Mansions before a on prior trip. Each time I was denied and put in parking lot view of the farthest corner of Parterre Place. I paid for standard view so I definately got it!
At CBR, I asked for ANYTHING but Trinidad South. I was solo and did not want to be so isolated from the rest of the world. When I checked in, of course I got Trinidad South. I begged to be placed elsewhere but the CM said no - try it out you will like it. It was OK, but I felt so far out of the loop, and I resorted to driving to the food court. I will pay for preferred next time!
At AKL, I was traveling with my sister and her two girls, ages 8 and 10 and requested bunk beds. I picked AKL solely to get bunk beds. We had a pool view room reserved. When we checked in, got two queens, absolutely no bunk beds available. We made do, but I will bring an air matress next time, as I learned my lesson.
At WL, I had a standard view reserved, and they "upgraded" me to a ground floor woods view - directly next to the fence around the loading dock. For a solo female, this is the WORST location - just did not make me feel safe. I really wanted a higher floor but the CM said I have to keep my room, nothing else available.
At CSR, I did get a request once - I asked for the Ranchos!!! But when I checked in, the computer kept trying to put me in the Casitas (where I stayed on two prior trips), but the CM kept trying and finally did get me a Ranchos room, and it was great! Isn't that funny - I almost was refused the worst section of CSR!
I think alot of my "bad" luck has to do with traveling solo. I guess solos are the perfect candidate to fill up the least desirable rooms so the families can have the better ones? Guess it makes sense. And everytime I didn't get a room request, the CM checking me in was also female. Almost like they won't go out of their way to help you? Another DISer once wrote that when she checked in, the CM would not grant requests, but when her husband came to complain, he got everything they wanted. Tis the way the world works, I guess.
Nowadays, I stopped making requests as I feel they are competely useless. For moderates, I will only pay for the better views or preferred for now on, since "the luck of the draw" never worked for me!
