We just had Touring Plans send in our request. has been hit and miss on rooms.
Yes, because no matter how they are made, requests are only that.
I have had the best results by NOT requesting a specific room but the general area (Yes, I pick one on the TP maps, but I leave the pre-populated field as-is since it is in room assigner speak - the terms they understand), and then in the additional comments box I prioritize what I want.
Example of that comments box from my trip to Sports a few years ago:
I would like to request that my room be...
1st priority - Surf’s Up section
2nd priority - Top Floor
3rd priority - Corner room
That way the assigner knew what to look for first (Surf’s Up section), then second (top floor), and then if rooms met those two, look for a corner room. Had top floor not been available, theoretically the assigner would have looked for corner rooms. I ended up with Surf’s Up, top floor, one room away from the corner.
On the other hand, last fall I had a stay at POFQ where I requested 1st priority - One of the closer buildings to the main building (I forget the numbers now, but I think I listed 3 or 4 buildings) because I travel solo and would be arriving late at night; 2nd priority - Top Floor; 3rd priority - Corner room. I got 2nd and 3rd priority but was in the furthest building, which was not fun arriving between 1 and 2am. My suspicion is they may have initially assigned me to a closer building but someone arriving earlier complained so they found something that met the other two (and technically was an upgrade to River View) as the building I was in seemed rather empty.
We shall see how close they get to my requests at Pop for my trip on Friday - again an arrival between 1 and 2am.