I had two different experiences while at WDW two weeks ago. My good experience: I bought three ponchos b/c there was a 90% chance of rain the next day. It ended up not raining until after we were already back to the hotel for the night. I had thrown away the receipt b/c I was so sure we would use them, but they gave me a merchandise credit. It did require a manager's approval.
My bad experience: I asked for an exchange at Mouse Gear for my Mickey camera strap. I bought it at Mouse Gear in July, but didn't have a receipt. It is completely falling apart (all the stitching is coming apart--the strap is unusable). Yes, I used it on my camera, but a camera strap shouldn't fall apart in less than three months, especially when I don't use it everyday. The cast member was very short with me (so much so that a different cast member apologized to me), and told me that it had been more than 30 days, so I couldn't return it. I live in Tennessee, so that wasn't really an option. I was lucky to be back less than 90 days out. I was so shocked by the way she treated me that I left, but I really wish I had spoken with a manager. I tried again at the Emporium on the last day of my trip, and the manager said, "Just take it back to Mouse Gear (the only place that carries them), they'll give you a new one." Unfortunately, we were leaving, and I didn't have time to go back to Epcot. So disappointed. I had been eyeing that strap for years.
Anyway, it may depend on who you get, but ask for a manager if you want to question the cast member's response!
Thanks for sharing your story. DH has been eyeing that strap for a while and we decided not to get it last trip b/c there were 2 hanging there and one looked as if it was already coming apart, lose threads and stitching missing, etc and he was concerned about the quality. I thought it might be a fluke, so I had considered getting one next month when we go to put in his stocking but I think we will have to pass on this one.
have had 2 great experiences:
1. bought a plastic pouch for DS in May, got home and noticed it came apart and the slider didn't work. Went to Mousegears last week and asked if we could get a new one (didn't have the receipt); she said absolutely. We didn't even go to the register, she did it right there.
2. DS got a light saber in Hollywood studios on Tuesday of last week. It stopped working, so we went back and they gladly exchanged it.
We were told by both CM's, as long as it's an even exchange (item for item), it's no big deal at all- no matter how long you've had it.
When I was there last month, I bought something at DHS but then returned it to the resort gift store. I was told you can return it to any gift shop. They did say I needed my reciept.
So you can return it anywhere with a receipt, is what I took this to mean.
Don't know if it's different if you take it too the actual store you bought it from.
As usual, there are CMs who are not aware of policy changes. They should not have told you that. It is no longer the policy. I got the policy information direct from one of the new CM trainers. She is always up on the latest policy decisions. Unfortunately, Disney isn't that good at disseminating information. You got lucky. Don't expect it in the future.
I realize this is really silly, but when I saw this thread I thought back to the thread a few months ago where the OP was sad that someone (her mother in law, maybe?) had bought an ear hat for her daughter when that was the thing she herself was looking forward to buying for her daughter once they were in the parks.
You wouldn't be that poster's mother in law returning the ones you bought, would you, OP?
(I realize I'm being silly. Ahem. I return you to your previously un-silly thread.)