Count me and my wife as looking forward to dining at Remy when we sail on the Fantasy. While $75.00 pp is steep, my understanding is that the experience is similar to what you get at V&A at the Grand Floridian (which, incidentally, costs $125.00pp for the main dining room, and $200.00 pp for the Chef's Table) -- if so, then Remy's could be a relative bargain. Add in the fact that the ship provides kids clubs to occupy our boys at no extra cost, and it is an even better bargain. That said, we will probably not order the wine pairings, and order a bottle (and perhaps a few extra glasses of wine) for the meal.
I also realize that the food at Remy is more in our comfort zone -- we've been through the long dinners at V&A's, as well as dinners in France and elsewhere in Europe -- before kids (3 hours is on the short side in some French restaurants). Having been through those meals (with multiple smaller dishes), I enjoy the variety and have never walked away unsatisfied or feeling cheated. In fact, if you are adventurous and willing to try new and different foods and food combinations, you could be pleasantly surprised. The purpose of this kind of meal is not to fill up and run; the purpose is to use more than just your sense of taste -- to appreciate how the presentation looks, the aroma, and the texture in your mouth (as well as the taste of the exotic ingredients). Watch the judges on
Iron Chef sometime -- they are appreciating more than how the food tastes (and most of them are serious foodies). You are also paying something for the experience and the quality of the service -- the difference between a one star and a three star restaurant is usually not the food, but in the service (anticipating your needs before you do) and the overall experience.
The main dining rooms, and more so Palo, try to do a little of this -- Remy takes it one step further. If you think Palo is a scary experience, then Remy will probably not be for you. Also, everyone has different tolerances for the price of things. While you might not think $75pp at Remy (or $174 pp with wine pairings) is worth it, you might think the same amount or higher amounts spent on spa treatments, a
Castaway Cay private cabana, or concierge level cabins on the same cruise are worth the prices -- and I might disagree with you.
DCL offers you multiple opportunities to part with your hard earned cash, and we all have our own priorities.