Here is the number for Debbie, 407-566-7411. You'll need to have your reservation number handy when you call. I phoned her at 60 days out, when the cruise was paid in full.
As for the best rotation to request, that's all personal preference. The request can't be guaranteed, so worst case scenario is that you can double dip and still experience it all. Keep in the mind that for the 4 night cruise, you'll repeat the same restaurant on the 4th night, that you dined in on the 1st. The menu is the currently the Master Chef version for that night. The only thing is that if you have Animators Palate for the first night, that is when you'd see their light show. It's not repeated on the 4th night.
I ended up looking through all the menus and decided that Parrot Cay was the least appealing to me. I chose the rotation of PLAP and we're eating at Palo's on our first night. The reason that I went with that, is I'd like to experience the night life over at the Atlantis in Nassau on our 2nd night. Dinner at Palo's on the 3rd night followed by brunch in the morning, or brunch followed by dinner on the 4th night seemed a bit too much for me.
Tammi