Rate these 3 restaurants please

[Tiggerlovinggrandma]

Give me your rating and opinion of these three restaurants:

California Grill

Narcoossee's

Yachtman's Steakhouse

 

[Blessedx3]

We have been to all three and love them all.

CG's veiws cannot be beat even if you aren't there for the fireworks. The food was great.

Nacroosee's food was awesome, service was excellent. Still not quiet but quieter then CG.


Yachtmens was one of the best steaks I have had. The quietest. Very nice.


I wouldn't hesitate to go to any of them again.

 

[ROEDISNEY]

California Grill Loved it! 10 would pick first

Narcoossee's Loved it! 10

Yachtman's Steakhouse never been

 

[jimmalru80]

1) California Grill
2) Yachtsman's Steakhouse
3) Narcoossees

 

[james'mommy]

Narcoossee's rock. We go every trip.

 

[tiggr33]

Of your choices.
1 = CG
2 = Yachtsman Steakhose
and as a distant third Narcoosees.

 

[MickeyNicki]

Well we have been to Yachtsman twice and loved it both times....great food. We are going to try Cali Grill in Oct because we have never heard a negative thing about it

 

[Amy&Dan]

I have done CG and Yachtsmen. CG was a bit disappointing to me, it was so noisy and my entree (pork tenderloin) was awful. Dh got a steak that was wonderful however. The views are nice but our table wasn't near a window so that was a bummer. I might eat there again, but it wasn't the stellar experience I was expecting. Not by a long shot.

Yachtsmen was incredible. The best meal I have had in a very long time. It was a wonderful experience, the best steaks I have had in my life, the service was exceptional and the atmosphere while not as "wow factor" as CG with its views was really nice, a great place to enjoy a quiet meal. We had a nice view of Stormalong Bay and a nice view of Illuminations (the high up fireworks that is). It was our standout meal in 12 trips to Disney. I will definitely return to this one again.

 

[wdwhereicome]

#1 Yachtsman - Absolutely perfect if you want an excellent steak!
#2 California Grill - Perfect spot for fireworks!
#3 Narcoossees - Only because we haven't been there yet.

 

[TinkerKel]

we have been to all 3, and had great experiences at all!
CG - the view is amazing, we love the food - our top pick in WDW
Narcoosee's - also wonderful. we found the ambiance here a bit more romantic than CG, a bit quieter. we loved the food, and again, an amazing view.
Yachtsman - excellent meal - dh and i loved our appetizers almost as much as our steaks!
i would highly recommend all 3!

 

[4everluvDisney]

We have been to all three and have enjoyed them many times.
The view from CG for Wishes is awesome. If you don't have a window seat it is always nice to go out on the deck and watch from there. The food is great too. The staff is some of the best anywhere on Disney property.
Love the seafood at Narcoosee's and you can watch the Electrical Water Pageant from there.
Want a delicious steak, head over to the Yachtsman Steakhouse.

Whichever you choose just go and enjoy!!

 

[aubriee]

I ate at all three this past May and Narcoosee is the only one I'm repeating for our Sept trip. It was the best meal of the entire trip and the steak I had there was MUCH better than the ones I had at Yatchsman and California Grill a few nights before. I'd rank them:

1. Narcoosee--excellent service, great steak and lobster, best dessert on property (almond crusted cheesecake ), quieter than the other two.

2. California Grill--great view, worst steak of the three restaurants, only place (besides Tutto Italia) where the waiter mentioned his tip wasn't included with the DxDDP. Great sushi! Loudest of the three.

3. Yatchsman--steak just OK (better here at home), excellent service, no atmosphere, not impressed with any of the desserts