A friend and I went during our last trip in August and really enjoyed it. It was one of our favorite choices that week, and we ate at a lot of nice places that trip (Boma, Citricos, Brown Derby, Le Cellier...). The food was great, and we didn't have the portion size problem Maggs did. The service was fairly good, though not as fabulous as we had at some of the signature dining we did that week. That's probably to be expected though, as it was a lot more crowded and it's just not as fancy of a restaurant. There was nothing about our waitress that we could complain about, you could just tell she was busy busy busy and might have been feeling a little overwhelmed. We found the restaurant to be a really attractive space with good ambiance, though we were there during the entertainment and it was LOUD. We found the musician (a guy that sang and played several instruments) to be pretty entertaining though so we didn't really mind. It's just something to keep in mind if noise bothers you. It was even a bit noisy before the musician came on, I think that's just the acoustics of the space.
We also found the prices to be pretty decent. It wasn't cheap by standards we'd have if we were eating out back home, but they were fair for what we got and for being on Disney property. I think we got out of there with about $30-$40 a person, which isn't too bad considering we both had multiple drinks over the course of dinner. My friend and I are planning on going back to WDW this fall for F&W and we'd consider making ADRs here again.
Oh and if it makes a difference, I had the Serious Sirloin (a steak I found to be better than the barbecued filet I had at Le Cellier, and I'm not one of those who has had a bad Le Cellier experience) and the Bailey's Creme Brule. Sarah had the rack of lamb with some sort of wine sauce, which I think was one of their daily specials at the time, and the bread pudding. No appetizers, but we both enjoyed the soda bread they have. We thought this place would be fun to either have a full meal at or to go to for drinks.