We were there for 10 nights in July 2005. We have stayed at both the RPR and PBH many, many times. Both resorts are fantastic.
In July 2005, we had the Villa suite (PBH) with both bedrooms attached. This was our Platinum Loews upgrade suite.
We also had a rate discrepancy when we checked in. The one bedroom was our deluxe room, booked at the internet special price (which was a Loews benefit rate.) The parlor was booked at $0.00 as our Loews upgrade benefit. But the second bedroom, which was supposed to also be booked at the Internet Special rate was listed at rack rate.
I also had all my confirmation e-mails and the names of the people I spoke to when I checked my reservation before we flew down and found the problem. They said just to go to check-in and it would be fixed.
The management jumped over hoops to get it fixed. Had to wait for the manager to get off the phone (about 10 minutes) to authorize the change, but that is all it took. In fact, since I had an AP, they dropped the rate even further from the Internet special rate- charging the second bedroom at the AP rate, even though I was getting the Platinum Loews upgrade and the AP rate is NOT a Loews benefit rate. So even though I was booking one of their choice suites (since only 2 of the villas have balconies) at cheap rates, they still even actually lowered my price for me.
Guess it just matters what day and what manager is there, but we have never had a problem in all our stays there.
The place is beautiful and the stroll to HRH is about 10 minutes if you want to use their pool too. We liked their cabanas better, so we rented a couple of cabanas for the day and spent the entire day and evening there. I walked back to the PBH a couple of times to get something and it was not a hassle.
Everybody's criteria is different, but we too are hotel snobs and love the place.