Question for you Dis'ers.......about childs birthday presents

npmommie

<font color=red>Channels George Michael in her car
Joined
Oct 11, 2007
Messages
7,378
we went to a birthday party today, a little while after the birthday boy opened his gifts, his older brother got all pouty with the mom, and asked where his present is.
I asked her what was up, and she told me every year she always gets the other child a gift as well as the child having a birthday.
she said she has always done this.
Does anyone else do this?
she asked me if I did this and I said no, i didn't even think of doing this.
 
No.. we dont do that! If its the boys birthday, he gets something.. and if its the girls.. SHE gets something.
 
she said she began doing this because she didn't want the other child to be upset, and wonder why they weren't getting a present too
she seemed surprised that i didn't do it too.
 
No. I have never done this and have no plans to start.

You get presents on YOUR birthday and that is that.

I had never heard of such a thing as getting a sibling a present on your birthday. Now bringing in treats to school for your birthday yes (although that stops at 6th grade)...until you are in the workforce & then could bring donuts in on your birthday. However, going out and getting other people gifts on YOUR birthday, is not a concept I'm even familiar with.
 
The kids have to learn that sometimes they don't get anything.
 
My DH's family does this. If anyone has a b-day, the kids get a present. ie. if I have a b-day, dd and nephew get a gift, if DD has a b-day, nephew gets gift, if SIL has b-day, DD and nephew get a gift.
It is a foreign concept to me and one that I just had to bite my tongue about. DD doesn't even enjoy it but it keeps the grown-ups happy. There are a lot of kids on my side of the family so she understands quite clearly that this is not a usual thing. I just try to tell myself it is like getting a treat bag at a b-day party.
 
I have never done this and I never will-well, the twins obviously get presents on the same day :rotfl2: .

Why do people think they are doing their children favors by doing stuff like this?
 
When I have children, I probably won't do this.

Since when do the siblings feel left out? They have their day too.. maybe it's different when they're really young but still, I feel like the child should know that it's their sibling's day and they will have their own on such and such a date.

But, hey, maybe this will change when I DO become a parent and it's easier to give both kids a present to keep 'em happy! :thumbsup2
 
I am SOOOO guilty of this.

Did you start doing this for the same reason my friend did? so as not to upset the other child?
she said her other kid would be upset when they were little.........so thats how it all began, but she just continued with it.

her kids are 9 ( just turned 9) and 11 ( and it was the 11 yo that was upset over the present thing) it was the 9 yos birthday party yesterday.
 
I have done it, but only once.

When my youngest turned 1, I did have a mommy/me day w/ my 4 y.o. a couple of days before her party. We went to the mall, shopped, ate lunch, and she got her ears pierced. I also kept her from preschool the day before the party and let her help me w/ the shopping, picking up the cake, etc.

My mom always got the other one something. Probably up until age 8 or so.

At 11, they should be over it.
 
I do it because I always felt that my other daughter would feel left out. They have never thrown fits or expected any of this....well, now I guess they have come to accept that when one is having a birthday, the other will get one small present. Just a couple weeks ago, my non-birthday daughter got a $15 Itunes card.
I like making both of my girls happy. I know this is not common practice. I know this is what is called "spoling" your child.....LOL.
I will still continue to do it.
 
I do it. My grandmother did it when my brother & I were growing up so I do it with my kids. Its something really small ($5 or less) & its 1 gift, while the others get 3-4 or more but we do give them a small gift. My birthday is in December & my brothers is in the summer so it was nice as a kid to get a little something at a time other than the month of December.

And I do give goodie bags.
 
Nope, never have, never will. I have three kids...35, 32, 15. When it's your birthday, it's 'your' birthday. When it's your brother's birthday, it's 'his' birthday..plain and simple.
The practice of handing out gifts to those who aren't celebrating the birthday, so they won't be upset, is the same mentality as giving every team in sports trophy's...don't want junior to feel left out, everyone 'deserves' a trophy. No, they don't. The champions deserve a trophy, get your kids a little something to acknowledge their hard work but it doesn't have to be huge.
Man....what ever happened to a birthday being someone's special day? How special can it be when everyone else gets gifts too?? My dd went to a birthday party, back when she was about 8, where the mom asked for each child to bring a gift in the $15 range...a girl would buy a girl gift, a boy would buy a boy gift. Then, they exchanged gifts...the birthday girl wasn't the only one getting gifts, and only got one. The purpose, I suppose, was to show that the party was about having fun being together, not about gifts. Another party she went to asked for gifts that were more specific...they were to go to a homeless shelter. So, the kids brought toiletries, books for kids, that type thing. These moms figured that their children lacked for nothing so needed no more 'gifts' but wanted them to enjoy a party with their friends. Interesting way of doing it, I thought.
 
I'm guilty of this as well........we didn't do it because the others would get upset becuse they never have. It just started in true Disney fashion as their 'Unbirthday" gift--we did it for many years but stopped and no one cared!
 
Never - kids need to learn to celebrate others. They get one day a year to celebrate themselves, and here, we have a party, they get to choose what they want for breakfast, and we go out to dinner to the restaurant of their choosing. Why should a sibling get a gift?
 
We've never done it. It seems like it would make a child think everything is about them. But I can see where in some cases it could be done in a fun way. I don't see the harm in it as long as the child doesn't always expect it and isn't a whiney, spoiled brat. The minute a kid whines about something though, is the time they should get nothing.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom