Based on the Poly fact sheet on Allearsnet.com, I think Tokelau is the best bet. We have never stayed there before, so I may be wrong. It was my first choice for room request. Samoa was my second and Niue was my third. Anyone have other opinions?
We always stay in Tokelau for the location. We often have a garden view room that actaully faces the quiet pool. We love room #3939 at the end of the hallway so that we can exit quickly down the stairs and be at TTC or GCH is minutes.
We were in the Tahiti longhouse two weeks ago. While it's farther from the GTC, we were really close to the TTC. Plus it was quiet and the beach is right next to the building! It took us less than 5 minutes to walk to the TTC. Have a great trip!
Tokelau--hands down. Second place would be Rarotonga. I list Rarotonga second because you have a 50% chance of getting a 'parking lot' view. With Tokelau both views are gorgeous lush garden views.