Q. for Non-Believers: Do you think all Christians are Conservatives?

Interesting you should think this bicker because as someone who tends more towards conservative ideas and is a Catholic, I don't get the impression that many people I know of liberal leanings try to include me in anything.
If true, then, based on my own experience and observations, I would guess that it is a reflection of the specific liberals that the specific social conservative has chosen to associate with, or the manner in which the specific social conservative chose to interact with them.

They basically write me off as someone who doesn't know what I am talking about because I am a religious person with conservative leanings...sort of a "poor sad little conservative Christian" attitude...condescending to say the least.
Surely that doesn't happen when a social conservative enters our church (to a fault, I suppose, some social conservatives would say [as if they have standing to say so :)]). However, I suspect, in other contexts, it has a lot to do with the social conservative's own capacity for practicing tolerance. If someone is actively practicing intolerance then (1) most everyone who is "other" will probably look (to the person actively practicing intolerance) as if they (the "others") are the ones who are intolerant; and (2) folks who are "other" may begin mirroring that disposition, as a defense against the attack that an intolerant person entering their space represents to them.

I think that a lot of staunch social conservatives confuse compromise with capitulation. Capitulation would be (for example) to afford substantial (even just logistical) significance to the holidays of some other spiritual perspective instead of that of one's own (like taking Samhain off work, instead of Christmas), or would be (for example) terminating an unwanted pregnancy instead of carrying it to term. By contrast, defending the rights of people to celebrate the holidays of their own spiritual perspectives, as their faith dictates, and defending the reproductive choice rights of others, as their conscience dictates rather than your own dictates, is actually the compromise position between the conservative and liberal perspective.

I am concerned that a lot of staunch social conservatives simply don't appreciate that allowing others to live in accordance with their own beliefs isn't capitulating to someone else's perspective but rather is peaceful compromise. Perhaps because they are left relatively unimpeded from practicing their social conservative values themselves, they adopt the mistaken impression that that means that everyone agrees with them, and therefore view any measure of compromise as capitulation on their part. That distortion on the part of social conservatives is the source of most belief-oriented ills in our society.

I get the impression that many of the more liberal folks I encounter on a day to day basis have the attitude that someone who is religious and conservative is obviously misguided.
I have experienced and observed dozens of socially conservative zealots who have projected that attitude. There are extremists on every side of every issue. That's the definition of the term "outlier" and the most remarkable observation possible regarding the measurement of outliers is when there aren't any... that is a truly remarkable thing when it happens. By contrast, the existence of outliers in any scenario that is naturally a normal distribution is to be expected. However, though I see the extremists on both sides, the social conservative extremists far outnumber the socially liberal extremists, IMHO.
 
I didnt say that a conservative cant have those values. I find my parents and their friends to be very loving kind and thoughtful... BUT having an open mind is not what I would classify them as having. My mother is a wonderful woman, but when the issues of the church and gays come up I cant say she has open mind. She reads the Bible one way and I read it another. The Episcopalians and the gay issue is a big hot bed in our church. I lean one way and my parents lean the other. It is a shame that our church has become divided on this issue.
Here is your previous post:

I have always been very socially liberal and very fiscally conservative. The money part comes from my parents and while my parents are very conservative socially, I am totally different. Its so funny, they get all bent out of shape on some of my social views now.. but I just laugh because honestly they raised me to be a liberal in that way. They raised me to be loving and kind and thoughtful and OPENMINDED on social issues.

You also did ascribe those values...loving, kind, thoughtful and open-minded...as LIBERAL values with which you were raised. You did not say "THE values", you said LIBERAL values. Actually what you said was that your conservative parents imparted those liberal values to you.

So, your open-mindedness does not extend to those whose values are different than yours?

Maybe that whole "open-minded" thing needs just a bit of work? ;)
 
If true, then, based on my own experience and observations, I would guess that it is a reflection of the specific liberals that the specific social conservative has chosen to associate with, or the manner in which the specific social conservative chose to interact with them.

Surely that doesn't happen when a social conservative enters our church (to a fault, I suppose, some social conservatives would say [as if they have standing to say so :)]). However, I suspect, in other contexts, it has a lot to do with the social conservative's own capacity for practicing tolerance. If someone is actively practicing intolerance then (1) most everyone who is "other" will probably look (to the person actively practicing intolerance) as if they (the "others") are the ones who are intolerant; and (2) folks who are "other" may begin mirroring that disposition, as a defense against the attack that an intolerant person entering their space represents to them.

I think that a lot of staunch social conservatives confuse compromise with capitulation. Capitulation would be (for example) to afford substantial (even just logistical) significance to the holidays of some other spiritual perspective instead of that of one's own (like taking Samhain off work, instead of Christmas), or would be (for example) terminating an unwanted pregnancy instead of carrying it to term. By contrast, defending the rights of people to celebrate the holidays of their own spiritual perspectives, as their faith dictates, and defending the reproductive choice rights of others, as their conscience dictates rather than your own dictates, is actually the compromise position between the conservative and liberal perspective.

I am concerned that a lot of staunch social conservatives simply don't appreciate that allowing others to live in accordance with their own beliefs isn't capitulating to someone else's perspective but rather is peaceful compromise. Perhaps because they are left relatively unimpeded from practicing their social conservative values themselves, they adopt the mistaken impression that that means that everyone agrees with them, and therefore view any measure of compromise as capitulation on their part. That distortion on the part of social conservatives is the source of most belief-oriented ills in our society.

I have experienced and observed dozens of socially conservative zealots who have projected that attitude. There are extremists on every side of every issue. That's the definition of the term "outlier" and the most remarkable observation possible regarding the measurement of outliers is when there aren't any... that is a truly remarkable thing when it happens. By contrast, the existence of outliers in any scenario that is naturally a normal distribution is to be expected. However, though I see the extremists on both sides, the social conservative extremists far outnumber the socially liberal extremists, IMHO.

You know, you & I have such different life experiences that sometimes when we post with each other, I feel like we live on 2 different planets. ;)

I'm a live and let live kind of person. I don't go spouting religion, I don't force people to try and believe in my religion, heck I don't even discuss religion unless I am directly asked. I have friends and acquaintances from all walks of life, all sorts of religions and ethnicities, all sorts of gender combinations...heterosexual, homosexual and even bisexual. I have married and single friends. I have very liberal and very conservative friends. In my daily life as a nurse, I have encountered probably every type of personality trait known to mankind, from the very "normal" to the very deviant...whatever those 2 extremes are. I find it interesting to speak with all kinds of people, find out thier beliefs and why they believe that way. In my world, the liberal extremists far outnumber the conservative extremists...but I live about an hour north of NYC, so maybe geography plays a part.

What I do know is that I spend a lot of time having folks roll their eyes at me and think that since I am a Catholic and lean to the right (& I don't lean to the far right either) that I can't possibly know what I am talking about or that my beliefs can't possibly be based on anything other than religious mumbo jumbo that I am stupid enough to believe. And they get really pissy when I say that I don't believe in something that they, as liberals, espouse. Because they, like the conservatives you speak of, seem to have "little capacity for practicing tolerance" of beliefs that are different from theirs. My theory is that each end of the social spectrum...liberal and conservative...needs to practice tolerance for the other end.

But that doesn't seem to be happening, from either end.
 
Thank goodness atheists don't have a bunch of religious rules to follow. :goodvibes
 
Maybe there is a difference between being religious and being religilous. :rotfl2:

Eeeep, I just caught my error. That 'n' in ever should not be there. :blush:
 
No, I know many Christians who are liberal in many of their views. Although I would call my self conservative, truthfully I am all over the place. I believe in smaller government but I do not believe in forcing others to abide by my morals. I could go on and on but I am sure you get the idea.

Talk to anyone I work with and they will tell you that not only does Christian mean conservative but also stupid, fools, misguided, ignorant and close minded. They publicly mock those who believe in Christian principals and any Christian ideas. This is all in a professional work environment with all high paid executives. I surely am bias in how I view liberals but I have not seen this open-minded and accepting view. All I see are people who are accepting if you agree with them. Fortunately, I am not ignorant enough to think that all liberal are like this. Although I do not understand how they can just group all conservatives. I guess it is just like this board, some of the more outspoken posters tend to be the most vocal of their ignorant opinions of the other side.
 
In my world, the liberal extremists far outnumber the conservative extremists...but I live about an hour north of NYC, so maybe geography plays a part.
My wife was living in Trumbull when we met. I think your estimate is simply wrong. I don't know why you'd even suggest it, knowing what I know about where you live.
 
I'm a liberal Christian, and I actually wrote a paper for a class in college about the Religious Left (really cool class, cross referenced b/w govt, religion and sociology, called "Christianity, Secularism and Democracy). The guy I was dating at the time's father told me there was no such thing as a Christian Left- that Christianity was inherently exclusive (ie "I am the way, the truth and the light; there is no way to the father except through me"- might not be perfectly quoted but I'm sure most will recognize the verse).

I feel that my liberal views come from my Christianity. I grew up working to help those less fortunate, welcoming those that might be judged elsewhere, etc as part of my church, and I personally feel that being liberal fits that better.
 
no such thing as a Christian Left- that Christianity was inherently exclusive

I'm always fascinated how the "experts" on Christianity (or any religion lambasted from the enlightened) have such a fundamental lack of understanding of it.
 
I'm always fascinated how the "experts" on Christianity (or any religion lambasted from the enlightened) have such a fundamental lack of understanding of it.

Yeah, I was so taken aback I think I said something like "I disagree" and then changed the subject. He was a nice guy (sanest member of that family, lol) but I was so frustrated that I didn't even want to start that discussion.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom