You use the same menu on the DP as you do if you pay out of pocket. There are some restaurants that do have an upcharge for certain meals, or have certain items that are not included. We never use the dining plan, so someone who is a pro will have a more specific answer about that. But in general, you can choose what you'd like from the menu: Drink, Entree, Dessert. (appetizer too, if you have the deluxe dining plan)