Priorities? -What's wrong with WDW instead of 2 cars?

what's already been said. I've saved and been frugal since I was a kid. I normally don't buy anything unless it's on sale. I put myself through college, and saved the downpayment for my home (which we bought a bit bigger than we originally needed due to a desire to increase the family!) I never had any $ problems due to my saving habits, until we bought this house. Now we get by, but do have a mortgage and a small bit of debt. The one thing that I insist on is my WDW annual vacation. I work for my $, and nobody else can tell me how to spend it. DH does express the desire to go other places, but I think we should then plan on saving the $ for both vacations. We get APs and try to use them for two vacations over two years, as well as use them to get other WDW savings. Our WDW trips an average of 9-11 days have cost us about 3,000/year (ok, more with souveniers) for DH, me, and now DD1. We stay at the onsite value resorts, and eat a lot of counter service. We don't live high on the hog at home, but I do bargain shop at sales a lot (spend more than I should in total). I would have to pay lot more for therapy if we didn't go to WDW. Our cars are '95 and '96, and with us having spent close to 5,500 on DH's car for repairs over the past couple years, I can say we will probably need to replace it soon. I would eat Mac & cheese twice a week if necessary to take my WDW trip. Cutting corners for the greater good is not that big a deal to me. DH thinks I'm nuts, though. I call WDW my sanity trip.
 
A new car will depreciate, family memories will appreciate. We are all investing wisely in my opinion!!!

I feel that the world is a less materialistic place after reading this thread! Thanks!
 
Welcome to DIS!!!

I agree with everyone...very frugal too...lost many friends, because I wasn't willing to spend away my husbands paycheck, and I didn't up grade to a "fabulous" house. I clip , crop, and do without. I invest heavily ... the couple of friends I have left don't know how I do it (but we all do). We love Disney and brought a DVC. I don't work, because I want to be home with my kids.


And could someone tell me exactly who has a clean home??? I have been cleaning all morning, and it could still be better!!
:crazy:
 
You know I used to think I was quite alone in the world on the way I felt about material possessions, now mind you I wasn't always like this, but I had to adapt a live and learn philosophy. When my husband and I first married, we both had good jobs, and everything else that goes along with it. We both had new cars, personal loans, credit cards, everything new, furniture payments, at the time we thought we were on top of the world, doing fine, well, we weren't. When I had our second child, I decided not to go back to work, and for the first year I was able to get 80% of my income due to a great insurance and medical leave program through my job. We were all right for a while then everything fell apart. My dh and I fought constantly, over our bills and debts, but eventually we let it all go. Now our life is so much better. We are such happier people, and we still have our bills but that is only our mortgage and utilities and car ins, home ins. We both drive used cars that are paid for, mine 95 honda accord, that is in great shape, his 95 chevy truck, good shape, and although we don't have the finest cars, and credit cards to use everywhere, we are in much better shape than anyone else around us. My bro in law and his wife fight all the time, and I've tried to tell them that their argues are mostly money related, and they should really think about downsizing their material possessions, but they don't, I guess having new cars every other year or so is just too important to some people. I know now what is important, and by having no extra expenses every month means we save more, and are able to spend more on small things we want like taking my kids places all summer, and vacations. We are much happier people and in my opinion we aren't missing out on anything. WDW is my fave place to be and despite people questoining us on why we keep going back, we will continue to go back, whenever possible.
Kim
 
Boy can I relate to this topic!! :rolleyes:

DH & I love Disney. I have loved Disney since I was a child, not WDW per say, since it wasn't until last year that I went for the first time ever. Not by choice, but just didn't have the funds.

Even last year when we planned our first Disney trip we got alot of "how can you afford that?" "don't you want other things instead" "why don't you go somewhere cheaper?" UGH!
Most of this came from the in-law side so it doesn't surprise me.

We are not rich, not even close. We have one car that has 165,000 miles on it but it is 100% ours! Although we do have to think about getting a newer-used one because things are staying to go wrong with our car.
I stay at home with my son. I clip coupons, I look for sales/clearances. I sell on Ebay & have garage sales to pay for our Disney trips.
We do have some debt, but we pay our bills every month.

We are leaving this Saturday for a trip to WDW. We have NOT even told my inlaws we are going again because we don't want to hear it!!!!!
They just don't understand & honestly I think they think we are shelling out $5,000+ & that just isn't the case.

The only one in my family that understands the Disney "bug" is my mother!

We don't even try to keep up with the "Jones". I think family time is more important then having a SUV in the driveway or a huge house. If you can have all those things & afford a Disney vacation, then more power to you....but we have to make choices because we can't have both. :)
 
This post hits me close to home (as you can tell, this is my 3rd response). :)

I have friends who deprive themselves of all fun things because they worry about the future. They live in a constant state of self-imposed poverty. They can never meet us for lunch, grab a movie. They have never left the island for a vacation. They make a decent living but do no such living with what they make. If they were happy hoarding their money, that would be one thing, but they are not. They constantly complain about not having, not being able to do this or that.

That's one end of the spectrum.

I have other friends who live high off the hog. They make more money than we do, but they have higher debt too. They continue to live their life exactly how they want to at the moment, not thinking of how they will pay for their first class tickets to this place or that. They constantly complain about their debt and feel trapped by their chosen life-style.

We try to live in the middle. We struggle with our decisions, but make family a priority. We save some for the future and spend some today. We have necessary debts like a mortgage and car payment, but try to stay away from excess.

I will never drive a Lexus or Mercedes. I will probably never stay at the Grand Californian or Grand Floridian. But I will take my DS to Disney as often as we can afford to go. I will build memories for my son with my parents and husband that will last him a lifetime. I will scrimp here and there and will splurge a little when we go to Disney. I will not regret the choices I have made for my family.

AND I will not judge my friends for their choices, (but I will help them plan their next trip to Disney, if they'll let me). ;)

Be happy all!:Pinkbounc
 
Yep, I get that from alot of our friends. They call me "the thrifty one" because I'm always buying on sale just so we can pay for our next WDW trip. I drive a 2000 Chrysler Town & Country, it's got all the room I need & it runs, so I'll drive it for a while. We do have a nice house, but I don't buy new clothes all the time, in fact I've bought none this year so far. They don't understand that either, but I'm a stay at home mom, what do I need a bunch of new clothes for - cleaning the toilets or pouring cereal?? I don't think so. I'll use that money instead for a trip to WDW.::yes::
 
So what's wrong with 2 cars instead of WDW? Or a nice house?

I understand what you are saying, and I think its easy to fall into the trap of judging someone elses spending - and bothersome when people do it - regardless of whether your mother in law questions your vacation habits or your best friend thinks the new boat might be overkill or your sister's husband swears up and down that all that money you save for your kids college funds is "wasted" because the kid won't get grants or scholarships if you save it. We trash a distant set of relatives all the time for the "poor" (from our point of view) financial choices they make (kids don't have snow boots, they live in North Dakota, but he can buy a camper - that's probably objectively poor finacial priorities). At the same time, its easy to sound like you are judging others for not chosing the same priorities as you.

Family memories don't need to be made in an expensive theme park. They can be made camping. They can be made during Sunday dinners at Grandma's house. To say "we choose WDW because we create memories that a nice house can't" seems to belittle my childhood memories (which don't include WDW, but do include a nice lake home - my families priorities were on the home on the lake - not vacations, we took one vacation that didn't involve visiting relatives - to WDW - when I was growing up - and that after I graduated from high school).

We are all fortunate to be able to afford Disney at all - if we have to give up something to do so, it is by definition the non-essentials (at least, I hope no one is starving their kids or going homeless while they save for Disney).

Another hidden message in the "Disney again" question is not financial. A lot of people have concerns (that they won't necessarily voice) about spoiling kids with unrealistic expectations. We really have to work in our house to balance what we can afford to give our children with what they can expect to live like once they leave the nest. This became important to us after watching my sister's ex crash and burn - a lifetime of Aspen for skiing, designer labels and new cars did not prepare him for a $38,000 a year salary out of college. For that reason, we don't take Disney vacations as often as we could afford to, and occationally do things like camp or picnic or other cheap and fun things - not to save money, but to help teach our children that they don't need to spend a lot of money to have a good time. Likewise, we seldom buy our kids expensive clothes, eat expensive food, etc.

Also, be careful of the "they make about as much as we do" trap. Its hard to guess someone's income by watching their spending - many people overspend, other's underspend. Its hard to know their income by what they do for a living - a lot of people inherit money. Or make significant amounts in investing. Or have stock options. Or get regular gifts from elderly relatives to avoid losing it in a nursing home or inheritence taxes. Its hard to know what someone's financial obligations are or aren't. We will not have turned 40 and won't have a house payment - that changes what we can spend significantly over someone with the same income. At the same time, more than 20% of our income goes into long term savings, that significantly changes what we can spend over someone not worrying about college and retirement. Several years ago, my close girlfriends and I had a chat about money - where we actually talk about salary and spending. Eye-opening. People I thought "made about what we did" made much less or much more. Friends who did well on a small income had a trust fund I didn't know about!
 
The bottom line is, it's your money. My husband and I have chosen to place our son in private school, but we do only have one child, and we have also chosen to live debt free so that we don't have to worry about paying a monthly payment, except to his school.
As far as disney goes, we go every year. It's not really not an option. We pre-pay everything. We get the comments every time "you're going AGAIN", but those that are making the comments are the ones that choose to dress themselves and their children to the nines, make frequent shopping trips for mounds of clothing for toddler children that will never even have the opportunity to wear the clothing before it's outgrown. My thought is, "it's a matter of priority!"
As far as making family memories, I have never regretted a single dime spent over a single second spent at WDW with my family. And not just because I have a child. I have also gone a few times without him with my mom, and haven't regretted that either!

The key is, where your treasure is, there where your heart be also.
 
Another thing to remember is that when your children grow up, they will remember the vacations that you spent together, but the car won't be one of those fond memories. When I was growing up, my parents priority was that we all take one long vacation each year (nothing exotic, just driving trips in the U.S.), but these trips gave us memories that still bring smiles after all these many (very, very many) years.
 
We hear that all the time....."You're going to Disney World AGAIN" "Don't you get bored??" "We want our kids to experience history!"
My neighbors have only one car..........he's an attorney and she works with him and the office is 1 mile from home. I personally couldn't be without transportation! We do like to keep our cars/van as long as possible. I had a 10 year old Oldsmobile that would not die.....we kept saying when we have to start putting $$ in it, we'd sell. Finally sold it with 120,000 miles on it and bought a new van because DD was growing out of her car seat and needed a shoulder strap for her booster seat.
 
It brought tears to my eyes to read the OP response about her FIL's death shortly after their trip to WDW. This next trip in August will be truly special to me because both my parents and my DH's father (he lost his mom in '96) will both be there. Also, my 3 sisters, BIL and 2 neices, cousins, etc. As I'm getting older, it's starting to hit me that my parents won't be around forever, and I need to cherish the time with them that I have. I know there are "other" things that I should spend the money on, but my in-laws live in Nebraska and my dh hasn't seen his family in 3 years, so it's worth it to us! Yes, we have debt, but we've never been late on payments, have a nice house, two cars, etc. I don't get my hair and nails done, don't spend lots of money on clothes, vacations are more important to me. Glad to see that everyone here is also putting their family first. I think we need more of that these days.
 
who care what others think, we spend a lot on disney and i am sure people spend what they can, i could think of quite a few more things i could do with all the money i spend but it is our choice and no one should knock you for it
 
i am there with everyone . we are going back to wdw next year. we have been wasting the hubby's paid vacations on doing stuff around here and after taking the trip this past march we won't ever waste time like that again. we are paying for our room week by week right now so that that is paid off and plan on paying for our tickets ahead of time also. only problem now is we are thinking of going to universal studios if they have the 5 for 2 day pass again next year. but i definetly don't want to cancel my reservation at the disney resort. that way we kind of have some of both worlds while down there. we are staying at the pop century resort next may. and i have planned on starting college in the fall when the kids go back to school so next year we can plan more and more after mommy gets a real good job lol.
never let anyone tell you what you should do. family comes first !
and i sure loved being able to enjoy time with my family in disney !
~claudette
 
I want to go on record and say. Who cares what others think? We get the same spiel too about going to Disney each and every year. And guess what everyone we are going again this August. DH and I feel the same way as all of you. Yes we need another vehicle. I just had another baby in December and now our Mazda 626 has a booster seat (DD6) and a car seat in the back(DS 5months). Yes its a little cramped but they are little people. NO we are not in a rush to buy another vehicle.Our SUV will have to wait until after August. We get more enjoyment out of our vacations to WDW. The memories we have created so far are so precious to us. A vehicle is just that, a vehicle. Means nothing to us but getting us from point A to B and back.

I truly understand how most of you all feel. You are not alone!
 
Originally posted by revrob

As far as making family memories, I have never regretted a single dime spent over a single second spent at WDW with my family. And not just because I have a child. I have also gone a few times without him with my mom, and haven't regretted that either!

The key is, where your treasure is, there where your heart be also.

Our family memories involve just DH and I, since we don't have kids--I agree, WDW memories are not just for children!:)
 
Originally posted by crisi
So what's wrong with 2 cars instead of WDW? Or a nice house?

I understand what you are saying, and I think its easy to fall into the trap of judging someone elses spending - and bothersome when people do it - regardless of whether your mother in law questions your vacation habits or your best friend thinks the new boat might be overkill or your sister's husband swears up and down that all that money you save for your kids college funds is "wasted" because the kid won't get grants or scholarships if you save it. We trash a distant set of relatives all the time for the "poor" (from our point of view) financial choices they make (kids don't have snow boots, they live in North Dakota, but he can buy a camper - that's probably objectively poor finacial priorities). At the same time, its easy to sound like you are judging others for not chosing the same priorities as you.

Family memories don't need to be made in an expensive theme park. They can be made camping. They can be made during Sunday dinners at Grandma's house. To say "we choose WDW because we create memories that a nice house can't" seems to belittle my childhood memories (which don't include WDW, but do include a nice lake home - my families priorities were on the home on the lake - not vacations, we took one vacation that didn't involve visiting relatives - to WDW - when I was growing up - and that after I graduated from high school).

Very well said. My childhood memories of family camping trips are great, and now I'm a Girl Scout leader and take my troops camping frequently, which seems to be an endangered experience in my neighborhood as many leaders won't camp! I do think some people make way too much of the "memories of Disney", but that's their right. My children will enjoy camping, a week at the beach, a visit to a city like Washington DC, etc.

To the original post, I think it is sad that friends would push someone to choose to spend money on their priorities. We all have our own comfort level. My personal priority is being debt-free. We keep our cars an average of 10 years. After 10 years of having no mortgage, we took out a home-equity loan to pay for an addition to the house, and I hate having that monthly payment again, but will pay it off as soon as I can. I think everyone should have a cash cushion for emergencies, but if a Disney vacation is your priority, people should just keep their mouths shut!
 
OK, I said that WDW was more fun than camping. And it is to us (I should have put that qualifier in there). I did not mean that one was necessarily better than the other. Just that they were similar experiences and the original poster should not have been made to feel like a permanent campsite was more important or better than Disney. They are both places for family memories, it's your choice. I apologize if I offended, it was not meant to sound that way.

No, you don't need an expensive theme park for good memories. We do lots of things with our kids (some that our parents did with us) that our kids will remember fondly (I hope) when they're older. We like to go to the small county fairs and the state fairs as well. We go to downtown Chicago to see the Field's tree and windows every Christmas. We go to Cruise Night in our small town and walk around looking at the fabulous cars and listening to great rock n roll (and eating ice cream). And we have movie nights at home, costing nothing more than maybe a pizza. Our kids have fun at all of these things.

But we also choose to go to Disney. And our memories there are worth every penny spent!

BTW, I did a week of GS camp last summer and will be out there with my troop this fall (took this summer off due to a new baby).

Sue

::MickeyMo ::MinnieMo pirate: princess: princess:
 
I am proud to say that I just paid the last pmt on dh's car this week and we plan to hold on to it until it dies, it's a Subaru, those things last forever (I hope ;) !)

Getting caught up with competing with the Jones'. Well, sometimes it hard not to. We live in a "medium" size house, 3 bdrms, 2.5 bath. Well all of dd's little girlfriends live in these big beautiful homes. Would I love one of those well yeah, but we can't afford it and continue to maintain our standard of living. I won't forget when we were having a Christmas party for dd (she's 7.5) one of the little girls, goes God your kitchen is small. Of course my response back was, but it works. I was just amazed by that comment. Yeah, I have house envy, but I also don't go out and buy a bigger house. Would I love an SUV, yeah, but can't justify spending that kind of money on a car and now with gas prices soaring, yikes! We do do a lot including owning DVC, which is the only reason that we can go to Disney every year. Dd does many different sports including gymnastics, soccer, dance, brownies and horseback riding. I would rather have her experience life with no regrets and to be able to make the choice in what she wants to concentrate on, rather than wishing that she could of done this or that as a child. If I had a bigger mortgage pmt or a big car pmt, she couldn't do these things. She also has a little brother who in a couple of yrs will be starting his own activities that also cost money. I would rather invest in the future and well being of my kids.

I would also like to add that the end of June last yr, my dh was laid off from his job, we thought that he would get something fairly quick, well it ended up taking 6 months for him to find something. He got a new job the same week that his unemployment ran out. If we had owned the bigger house or the big brand new cars, we would of been in deep do-do. Him losing his job has taught me a big lesson in life. Don't live above your means, because your means can dissapear. Luckily, my biggest concern was not to have my kids lives dissrupted (i.e. dd's sports and stuff.) That never happened. We did have to push back our originally scheduled Disney vacation from this past Feb to Aug, but we are surviving!

I guess bottom line for me is that to be honest, would I love to compete with the Jones' - YES - then reality hits and although at times I am envious, that is about as far as it goes REALITY CHECK:crazy:
 
or make that, same single car! ::yes::

We have one car and two small children. Our last trip was 3 years ago when dd#1 was 15 months old. Our next trip will be with dd (now 4) and dd#2 (just over 2 at time of trip). We've been carefully planning for over a year. We have the money saved, we are splurging to stay on property for the first time and do this exactly how we like to do it.

Until 3 months ago, we only had one income. I am fortunate to be able to work mostly from home to give us a second income and we are furiously saving for the trip we will plan when dd's are 6 & 4 and hoping to buy a house between now and then.

That's right, we don't even own our home. We rent. And Disney is still more important, at least this time around. So, if anyone thinks your priorities are out of whack, tell them about us! :teeth:
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom