I agree with many of your points, except "give it away". Adoption is not giving your child away. My daughter was not a free puppy I adopted from a
Walmart parking lot. Her biological mother did a lot more than just sign a paper, give me a bag of food and hand over a baby. I'm sorry but my mommy feathers are going to get ruffled anytime adoption is referred to as giving away a child, or that they would be better off in a home where they are
really wanted. To me this says they were unwanted to start with. I know you didn't say that but someone else has.
I too am appalled at those who suggested this for the mom to be. I'm sure she is well aware of her options and has chosen the one that she wants. I believe the OP is just being a big sister to her brother, heard there was a problem and came here seeking advice. It's a shame some of the responses she received, but that's the nature of internet questions. People are more likely to say what they are really thinking when they don't have to look you in the eye. Never once did I see where the OP said the parents to be asked her to ask these questions. Just that they were concerned over health insurance and she (meaning the OP, not the parents) wondered what other types of assistance the woman might be able to get. It's just been a downward spiral from there. As far as anyone knows the parents of this baby are just trying to figure out what needs to be done to make sure the child has some health insurance when it's born. Gees that's so irresponsible to plan ahead for a known cost. Let's drag them out in the street and get our tar and feathers.