Point and Shoot - Help please?

Nana2Callie

DIS Veteran
Joined
Jan 6, 2011
Messages
988
I have an opportunity to replace my Nikon coolpix camera (that is having issues anyway from being dropped a couple of times) with a new one. But, what do I buy? I haven't been crazy about the Cool Pix and have been considering a Canon or the Sony HX10V (or possibly the HX20V). All comments and suggestions appreciated. I'm not a camera whiz in any sense, but do enjoy taking lots of pictures.

Thanks,
 
I have 0 knowledge on P&S these days, but what will help others make suggestions is a few things...

1) What's your rough price range? This can make a huge difference as there are good P&S in the $150-$200 range and there are some excellent ones in the $500-$600 range, as well as a large amount of strong ones in between. (And some duds in any of those ranges as well)

2) What features are you looking for? Don't have to be technical or anything, but just a general idea of what you're looking to do (low light, action, all around, high optical zoom, shock-resistant ;), etc)
 
First. Point and shoot cameras are not the only thing in your price range. You can get an affordable and relatively compact mirrorless camera with a m3/4 sensor that dwarfs any tiny point and shoot sensor, and get big time photographic results. There is the Olympus PEN E-PL1 that can found under $300 or a slight upgrade for an E-PL2 or E-PM1

The mirrorless route does get more expensive if you need more zoom reach or want to match the video performance of the HX10.

I am a big fan of my HX30 (an HX20+ wifi). And would certainly recommend it for a very solid feeling camera with zoom, video, responsive, and really nice images SOOC.
Here's a link to my July trip report with pictures: http://disboards.com/showthread.php?t=2968238

But if you are not using the zoom and video then an enthuiast camera like the s95/s100 would be better in low light and get you pictures closer to DsLr quality

And I almost forgot, start reading reviews at Dpreview.com and then seek our some end user reviews on their forums and other sites). There is not a "best camera" all point and shoots are compromises. So you need to find the one that fits you and your usage best.
 

I have an opportunity to replace my Nikon coolpix camera (that is having issues anyway from being dropped a couple of times) with a new one. But, what do I buy? I haven't been crazy about the Cool Pix and have been considering a Canon or the Sony HX10V (or possibly the HX20V). All comments and suggestions appreciated. I'm not a camera whiz in any sense, but do enjoy taking lots of pictures.

Thanks,

There are a ton of great point and shoots. When you get recommendations you're getting what that person prefers and that may or may not be what's right for you, so keep that in mind. Start the search by making a list of features that are important to you. Get specific if you need to so you can narrow it down. Sites like dpreview.com are good places to compare and learn about features. THen research the cameras that make your list, eliminating any that seem to have issues that will be a problem for you. After that take your list of cameras and go to the store to play with them.
 
The SONY RX100 is very nice and portable. At they very top

Less money but not as portable FUJI X10

Panasonic LX7 less money portable

Canon S95/S100 not as nice as the LX7 but less money.

THese cameras range in the 300-650 range...

Below that I recomend Canon
 
As others have said, there is such a broad array. It's like just asking, "where should I go on vacation?" -- without knowing your tastes, your price range, etc.

The 2 most important priorities are probably size and price.
Do you want something that fits in your pocket, that you can carry everywhere? Or you ok with a camera that needs its own bag, or something in between? (Doesn't fit in your pocket, but still pretty light to carry around).
Price.... It's hard to get something "good" for under $200. But depending on your other priorities, you could be looking in the $200-$300 range, of the $1,000+ range.

The next question I would ask, is what are your priorities, how do you use your camera. Do you mostly post pictures on facebook or print 4X6's... or do you print 8X10's and larger? Do you generally photograph indoors in low light, or outdoors? Do you take a lot of candids and actions shots, or more posed and scenic? What's more important to you, image quality or a good reaching zoom?
How important is ease of use? All new cameras have pretty good automatic modes these days, but do you want the ability to apply more fine-tuned manual controls? Do you want the ability to expand on the camera, add lenses, etc. Or just a final product ready to go, out of the box?

There are other factors, but these are the big ones.
 
A little more information - sorry I didn't include before:

Price range: $400 or less

Size: Average, prefer the slim style, but realize getting more features may require a bigger camera. I'm okay with that as long as it is still portable and easy to carry around a theme park all day.

Features: Recovery is important, taking photos of GD and she has often moved by the time the Nikon focuses. I do zoom a fair amount and would also to take action shots.

I print all photos, but mostly 4x6 occassionally will do a 5x7.

Video - is an option I'm interested since we do not have a video camera, but we need to learn how to use it.

Ease of use is important too. The Nikon has some nice features, but getting to them is a little cumbersome so I often just skip them.

Thanks again...
 
You can find the Nikon J1 for under $450 these days. It is very easy to use, with high image quality and blazing fast focus speeds. It is small, though bigger than a "compact." In your case, the down side is that the included lens does not have a big zoom. Though it has interchangeable lenses, so you could add a zoom lens.

If you are willing to venture into a slightly larger mirrorless, you can get a Sony Nex3 for under $400 these days. Very high image quality (it is SLR quality), has a fast focus system. It is still relatively light and easy to carry. But again, you would have to add lenses for a big zoom.

Returning to fixed lens systems --
For under $400, the Canon S95 and S100 are the best rated for image quality, but don't have a big zoom.
the Sony Cyber-shot DSC-HX20 and HX30 get pretty good reviews overall. Lots of good features, and super zoom. Though the image quality won't be as high as the prior cameras. I don't have personal experience with this camera, so I'll let someone else comment on focus speed.

There is the Canon Powershot SX260 -- My wife has an earlier model. I recommend it for people looking for big zoom, in a very compact camera. Good overall results. Focus speed and quality is about what you'd expect in the price. Certainly not bad.
 
Slow auto focus is a common problem in photography. That's where anticipation and pre-focusing come in really handy. As does really getting to know the auto focus system on a particular camera so you know which AF modes to use when.

I think print size is pretty irrelevant to even consider these days. You can make really nice 11x14 prints from a good quality 4MP image and pretty much every current model camera out right now has more than that. An 8MP camera will get you large 24x36 prints very easily. Again, most current models are more than 8MP. So you shouldn't have to worry about that aspect.

Zoom... this is where you'll have to decide. Pocket camera or super zoom. Are you good with 5x zoom or do you want to go all out with like 20x zoom? Or is somewhere in between good?
 
A good point and shoot can have a good recovery time some even have facial tracking that you can use (where they track movement). And they would usually have a 'sport' mode you could select (though this can be on a in camera menu) which is helpful when taking pictures of kids. Some have tough screen so you can touch and focus in on the subject quickly. Motion pictures can be hard to get on any digital camera though. And usually the video mode isn't too shabby either. As a tip don't buy just on megapixels, andy new camera on the market should have enough to make sharp prints at or above 8x10.

Personally I use and love my Panasonic Lumix DMC (it has awesome zoom). I've had two I loved the first one so much (I took it on study abroad and it held up remarkably well for being crammed in my backpack for six months) that I bought another one after I broke the first.

I use cnet camera reviews a lot when I'm shopping. Its easy to get overwhelmed with camera suggestions there but you can filter by what you are looking for such as 'best compact digital cameras'. Also you might want to check out the Amazon reviews for a camera you are thinking about and make sure they are majority positive.
 
Have you considered the Canon G Series? I am a nikon SLR shooter but the G12 is my P+S.
 
No, but I will take a look. At the camera store - the guy suggested that Canon pictures were grainy. I'm sure this was a personal opinion.
 
A little more information - sorry I didn't include before:

Price range: $400 or less

Size: Average, prefer the slim style, but realize getting more features may require a bigger camera. I'm okay with that as long as it is still portable and easy to carry around a theme park all day.

Features: Recovery is important, taking photos of GD and she has often moved by the time the Nikon focuses. I do zoom a fair amount and would also to take action shots.

I print all photos, but mostly 4x6 occassionally will do a 5x7.

Video - is an option I'm interested since we do not have a video camera, but we need to learn how to use it.

Ease of use is important too. The Nikon has some nice features, but getting to them is a little cumbersome so I often just skip them.

Thanks again...
Based on the bolded I think you are wise to stick with something you're familiar with, maybe with video - i.e. a compact point and shoot with video. There are many fans of Panasonic, Canon and Sony here. Which model you choose is like photo chick says in post #5 above. You should also read up on Noise in cameras i.e. graininess to give you a better understanding of what the guy in the store was talking about. No matter what camera you buy, learning to use it to its fullest will yield you your best results. Good luck!
 
Just wanted to say thank you and that I purchased the Sony HX30V which should be arriving today or tomorrow.
 




















Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE









DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom