Thank you for your feedback. The more that I think about it, I may cancel the Tusker House breakfast. I added a reservation for Easter Brunch at Narcoossees. Our ressie at Sanaa is at 5pm (thought we would have a good chance of getting a seat by the window) and we really want to try it!
We can still get to AK early for our Safari FP. I also have the character meet and greet as a FP. I can bank that credit and use it for Narcoossees instead. I crunched the numbers and it is smarter to pay out of pocket for HDDR with gratuity and tax included in the price. I will also pay out of pocket for The Plaza. We have never been to Narcoossees and it will be a special splurge and a great way to celebrate Easter.
While other parents really love breakfast character meals, I have a hard time paying so much for eggs and such, plus my kids will just eat a muffin. I totally get that you are paying for the total experience. This slightly contradicts using two credits at Narcoossees. But it is about $70 for an adult and it some with a great variety plus a little alcohol (and $40 for child). Not the very best value on dining plan but not the worst either. They may even do something special for Easter Sunday?!
I would spend the 2TS on Narcoosees Brunch. It sounds like it is going to hit all the right spots for you guys - food more like california grill, at the GF and the atmosphere/location is just outright stunning beautiful. It is right on valuewise too, maybe a few $$ light for the adults but you're pretty much there for the kids on par with character meals that are about $20 (x2 for 2TS). I had this struggle too when figuring out my reservations for an upcoming trip and decided to do my CP meal out of pocket. I just couldn't justify burning the 2TS for $58.99 for lunch (though it will prob go up next year) but more importantly only $14.99 for the kiddo when I can have $40-50 worth of character buffets for the same credits. So it is one of the more pricey adult meals and not a great use of credits but the kid price killed it for me using the plan. It's ok because I have 7 other meals on the plan (including one character breakfast) and I'm looking forward to all of them! I booked the Ohana breakfast as it was one of the highlights. I love to be able to relax and have breakfast served to us and my kid will eat his weight in mickey waffles and bacon and I will eat his weight in fruit

But one breakfast buffet for the week is plenty for us - I am doing the tusker house lunch and last time I booked an early ADR and it was still half breakfast and we ended up kind of picking at the meager lunch offerings until it all switched over. So I guess I am with you on most breakfast buffets but honestly did really enjoy Ohana. Also planning BoG breakfast because it is one of those "so pricey I'd never pay that OOP but now is a great time to experience it" things.
Since I have so long before I can even book I'm wondering if I should swap out some of my plans for a true signature. Right now the "best" i have is the CP at coral reef. I know the reviews are iffy here but it is an old favorite of mine honestly, first TS I ever did when I was on a HS trip with my best friend and never had a bad meal there. Hoping that an open time lunch ressie won't be a disappointment. But damn that lobster at Narcoossees looks so good to me! And I live in New England but lobster is mostly at tourist prices and no one breaks it open to that extent. But then I'm back to spending $8 for 2 kids TS. and I'd NEVER pay $70 for lobster OOP in a million years lol.
These are my plans right now and they sound pretty similar to yours:
Arrive sat afternoon, hoping to spend 2 nights at the new Poly
DVC
Ohana dinner
MK for MSEP with FP+ viewing and fireworks
Sunday morning AK
Tusker house Lunch
MVMCP evening with Casey's for dinner
Monday morning back to MK for BoG breakfast
do a few things there then head over to Boardwalk for check in and new allottment of DDP credits, lunch at the bakery where I will get the lobster roll lol (see above, another thing I don't indulge on that often around here... esp not in the winter)
Epcot for afternoon/evening with Garden Grill dinner
Tuesday
downtown disney morning
Wolfgang Puck for early lunch
Minnie's Hollywood and Vine Holiday Dine with fantasmic packagef or dinner
Wednesday
early to HS for Jedi Training academy
lunch at Sci Fi Dine in
Dinner at CS either boardwalk bakery again or Epcot somewhere, haven't decided
maybe sunshine seasons, maybe liberty inn (I have a picky kid so a lot of the QS at epcot are tough with him). Benefit of having it at the boardwalk bakery is that I can swap my drink for a second real dessert for the kiddo even if he orders a kid meal. Also there is a lot he will eat - ham and cheese sandwich, turkey sandwich, mac and cheese. We will have the mugs there since staying at the resort so can easily swap out other things for the drink that comes with the meal. I can have another lobster roll! and maybe a soup.
Thursday
all day epcot
CP package at Coral reef (oop)
dinner after CP at Morocco. it's close to the american theater, it has food that I like to eat and chicken tenders on the kid menu. WOOHOO
Friday on our last day back to MK
BoG lunch as early in the day as possible
CP dinner
Saturday morning
back to the poly for Ohana breakfast to bookend our stay before going to the airport for an afternoon flight.
So I'm really not sure what I'd want to give up for a signature meal except maybe CP dinner for a signature dinner on our last night but the kiddo loves pooh and I admit I am kind of a pooh fan too. But our meal at California Grill was lovely and my kid had a great time at a grownup meal. So I don't know! Sorry to hijack your post but we seem like we are mostly in a similar place with similar tastes lol. The repeats for us are Tusker House, Ohana breakfast, CP (which are the only character meals we did last time) and Sci Fi Dine in, which was his fav. Last time we also did California Grill but that has been dropped along with Kona Cafe, which I swapped out for Ohana this time. I have also added Garden Grill, Coral Reef, and H&V, so 2 more character meals... truth be told the character meals were even better than I anticipated last time and the CP was added at the last minute to squeeze another one in. I think the ONLY repeat on CS is wolfgang, I am trying a bunch of new ones this time including two BoG meals.