Please Rate These Signature Restaurants

[Kata]

I admit I seem to be a signature restauarant snob. Since I am resort hopping for 9 nights at different resorts I can only use the DDP for 3 signature restaurants so I need to pick 3 and either pay OOP for the rest or skip them. Please give me your advice. Thanks!!!!!!!!
My choices are Jiko,CG, Narcooses's, Artist Point,and Citricos. I really appreciate any feedback you can give me.Please share your opinions!!!!!
Thank You!!!!

 

[Pakey]

We are also signature dining fans (we don't do DDP because of this problem). I'm going to list mine in my favorite order, including the ones not on your list.
V&A, Bistro de Paris, JIKO, Ca Grill, Flying Fish, Artist Pointe, Narcoosie's and last would be Citricos. And I think Yachtsman Steakhouse might be considered signature also and if it is, I would rank that in between Artist Pointe and Narcoosies. We have eaten at all of these on several occasions so my ranking is based on the average experience. Although I wouldn't turn down a free meal at any one of them, Citrico's is definitely at the bottom of my list because the last 2 times there have been very disappointing (it takes 2 disappointments before I take a place off my list!!!).

 

[Uncleromulus]

All are quite good and I've been to all 5 any # of times. I'd rate them as California Grill, Jiko, Citricos, Artist Point, and finally Narcoossee's (where we had service issues last time there).

 

[Dana49]

We've dined at all 5 of the restaurants and all are pretty good in their own way. I would rate them: Jiko, CG, Citrico's, Artist Point, and Narcoossees.

 

[MadamMim]

I will preface this by saying that I'm one of those weird people who doesn't particularly like California Grill. I know, I know, I keep trying to like it, I know that I should, but I just don't. So apologies there. My ranking then would be Artist Point, Citricos, Narcoossee's, Jiko, and CG.

 

[Kata]

Thank you for all the great responses!!! I have been to CG and I really did enjoy it,but I ordered the pork tenderloin which was great but at about $26.00 for the entree I don't think it is worth it to use 2 TS credits at so if I go I will pay OOP. Artist Point does have a prixe fix menu for $51.00 which would be cheaper than most of the other meals I have planned at the other restaurants.I really want to eat at all of these restaurants so I will just have to look over the menus again and figure out how to do it with the least amount of OOP expense. Does anyone know if I can get a piece of the Almond cheesecake to go if I decide to skip eating Narcooses and just get dessert? I have heard such rave reviews about it I have to try it.
Thanks again!!!!!!!!

 

[BoomNLeon]

We only ate at 3 from your list, so here is the rating I would give.

Cali Grill
Jiko
Artist Point

They were all very good, but in different ways. Our evening at the Cali Grill was really great. Service was great, food was great. We had a late ADR (9:50), so we pretty much had the run of the place. Jiko was really great, but we were the first table sat that night. Artist Point is a cavernous space, but the food was really good and the server knew his wines and the menu very well.

Hope you enjoy!