Please help me decide!?!?

[candleonwater]

Okay, yes, I'm still going round and round with this one. Right now I've ressies at BC for our Halloween trip. It's just me, my mother and my daughter. For almost the exact same amount... we could have two water view rooms at POFQ. Both of these are resorts we have stayed at before, so I know what each offers. The two major pluses for BC are the pool (and we do make use of it) and it's proximity to EPCOT. This time though, I'd like to try taking the boat to MGM and walking over to the Boardwalk.

POFQ pluses... love the grounds... LOVE the food court - we're not big into sit down meals, especially breakfast. Also loved the boat to POR and DD. Downside, having to bus to all the parks, and the pool...

The idea of two bathrooms isn't a big deal, and once upon a time the two connecting rooms (giving a suite-feeling) were necessary so that my daughter could get to sleep at night. Now, she's good about collapsing and sleeping with lights on.

Any ideas which of these is more likely to offer a bigger discount at that time of year?

Are there any other pluses/minuses I've missed?

I hate having to make decisions like this!

 

[onceuponadream]

I've never stayed at BC (have a good friend who has) but I've stayed at POFQ. Here's my thoughts. There are only 3 of you travelling right? A room at the BC should be more than ample as they have a daybed and you will each have your own bed. From what I've read (and my friend has told me) BC is awesome..the pool and the location plus the plush accomodations and its been newly refurbed. I would definitely stay at BC and save 2 rooms at POFQ for a time when I needed more space. Good luck deciding! .