Seeing more pictures of the interior, I am less disappointed in the theming. I think they did a nice job of combining the NY theme with the Muppet theme without making either terribly overwhelming. (And interesting that it is a "New York-ish" Pizza place in California, in a theme park in Florida.)
Still disappointed that the Pizza is typical Disney junk pizza, especially when they've started serviing a pretty tasty flatbread in a lot of QS locations. My guess is we'll probably still give it a try once, but that'll be it.