My boys, 13 and 10, both liked the Pirate Adventure (treasure hunt) as well as Sorcerers of the Magic Kingdom. But they did like Sorcerers of the Magic Kingdom more (and spent more time working on that and collecting cards each day). The nice thing about the Pirate Adventure is that it is all held within Adventure Land, where as Sorcerers of the Magic Kingdom was all over the park. I believe you get to keep the maps that you get when doing the Pirate Adventure (and it's good practice for the kids to read a map and look for details). And for Sorcerers of the Magic Kingdom you collect and keep the cards (on pack each day you are at the Magic Kingdom and a bonus pack when you complete a full mission-it took my boys 3 days to fully complete a mission...though they were only DEDICATED to playing it one day when we split up so they could run around the park finishing their quest). If you have questions you want answered, let me know and I can poll my two boys. But they tell me they were both fun (as well as Perry's Adventure in EPCOT)