He also isn't AKC, which seems to have another group up in arms. He's a great dog. He's funny, loving, smart, and a great member of our family.
I am an ancient show dog person, but I am also of the growing group of people who realize that while we show people breed to better our breed, we cannot possibly keep up with the demand for pet quality family members.
We cannot complain about people buying from petshops and backyard breeders if we also make it almost impossible to get a puppy from a responsible breeder.
So, the solution is to mentor backyard breeders in raising litters responsibly.
So, a responsible breeder does not have to have AKC dogs. They could be your JackRats or, even though it makes me shudder, Golden Doodles.
BUT...A responsible breeder will....
1) do all the health certifications before they put a litter on the ground. That means hips, eyes, elbows, cardiac, thyroid, addison's disease, and any and all diseases that are common to the parents' breed(s) need to be checked before they breed the dog.
2) not breed two dogs just for profit. There has to be a well thought out reason for breeding two dogs together before doing it.
3) make sure all puppies, whether AKC or not, are sold on a spay/neuter contract and follow up to make sure it is done. Or do early spay/neuters before the puppies even leave their home.
4) keep the puppies until they are actually ready to leave. That means no puppy goes to a new home before 8 weeks, preferably 12 weeks.
5) know the history of the dogs they are breeding. Does the cocker they are breeding to the poodle have a history of temperament issues? Cockers, due to overbreeding by puppy mills have had their temperaments notoriously ruined. A good breeder will not breed a dog with a questionable temperament just to create a litter for profit.
6) will stand behind their puppies for a lifetime, including microchipping with their info.
7) be available for the lifetime of the dog if you have questions about training or anything that might happen to the dog. They do not just take your money and disappear. You should be able to go back to the breeder at any time with questions about house training, temperament issues, etc.
7) will have buyers lined up for a litter before they produce it. They will ask questions of the family, temperament test the puppies, and place the best suited puppy with each family.
You can find breeders - whether they are breeding top notch show dogs or the latest designer fad - that follow the ethics of a responsible breeder. You should be comfortable getting that puppy, knowing that the breeder put a lot of thought in that litter instead of just how it was going to pad their bank account.
Do your research. Don't buy that puppy, no matter how cute or how sorry you feel for it in the pet shop window. You can have a quality dog, for a decent price, without supporting the puppy mills or the unethical backyard breeders. Ask to see the cerf test, the OFA results, the cardiac results.
A family member who is going to spend the next 10 - 18 years in your home deserves the same kind of research that you would do for your next car, big screen tv or refrigerator. It should never be an impulse buy. Impulse buys are the main reason that dogs end up in shelters.