I think they're the same thing, and we much preferred Parrot Cay. Cooler, more seating, better service. It can be hard to find things that the kids (and even myself and other adults) like sometimes, but there is always fruit, ice cream, salads, and carved beef. Even hot dogs. When we travel, if my kids can't find something they like as "real" food, I will let them just eat desserts. I'm more concerned with them having a full stomach than the nutritional value.....they get that at home.