Paddlefish or The Boathouse?

[Snatit4387]

Hoping for recommendations! I'll be at Disney World from 9/30-10/4 and planning to be at Disney Springs on 9/30. I'm toying with the idea of a late lunch/early dinner at either Paddlefish or The Boathouse, but can't decide on which... Does anyone have strong preferences for one over the other? How would you rate these restaurants?

 

[gatordoc]

Drinks were better at the Boathouse. Seafood and service were better at Paddlefish.

 

[KimBean]

Drinks were better at the Boathouse. Seafood and service were better at Paddlefish.

Glad to hear this. Have a ressie for Paddlefish.

 

[thaggie1]

There have been past threads on this and Boathouse has been the favorite.

 

[BK2014]

I did not vote, because I have only tried the Boathouse and am planning on trying Paddlefish on the next trip. No complaints whatsoever about the Boathouse. Great food, great service. We splurged on the Amphicar ride. It poured for about 5 minutes of the ride, but made for a fun memory. Thought it was fun.