With the Silver Plan you will be paying approx. $33.50 per wish for adults and Jr. (age 10 - 17) and $27.00 per wish per child (3-9). Most of the kids meal are around $6.00. Tax and gratuity are included. As you stated your kids are not big eaters. We just used the Silver Plan and it worked great for us. We have an 11 & 7yr old. The 11yr old eats very well, so it worked for him. The 7 yr old was required to choose from the kids menu so it's not a good deal for him. We did pay cash a few times for the 7yr olds kids meal and used the wishes for something of more value (boat rental, pin kit). Also I'm not sure that you will be able to eat 2 big meals each day. Included w/Silver Plan you get a choice of appitizer OR soup OR salad, entree, dessert, non-alcoholic beverage and dessert, coffee. I hope this helps.