Our dinner--with a crowd--at Citricos

Uncleromulus

Plain grey will be fine
Joined
Jan 28, 2001
Messages
15,529
First night dinner choice this trip was Citricos-and we were looking forward to the return. Had been a few years since we were last there, and our last attempt to get ADR's had been foiled by a scheduled Australian Wine tasting affair that closed down the entire restaurant.
Our ADR's were for 8:00 and when we arrived fashionably early at about 7:50--the place was swamped!! More crowded than I had ever seen it, and a 20 minute wait to be seated!! This was actually good to see--our previous meals there were at a restaurant that was embarassingly empty. And even more suprising were the # of kids!! More than at any other place we dined at all week. I may now have to revise my usual recommendation as Citricos being a "quiet" place to eat!! But everyone was well behaved and as with the crowd in general, it was kind of good to see them have all the business.

We were led to our table at about 8:15 or so and wound up sitting with a "kitchen view'". I always forget that Citricos has a open kitchen, and our table was right along the railing that separates the dining room from the area where the servers pick up the food. We could see and hear everything and actually spoke with a couple of the chefs who had come out of the kitchen to expedite things. Was almost a "poor mans" Chefs table!! And I am amazed at how they handled all the business. We kept hearing things like "6 veal shank" and "4 filets-2 well, one medium, one rare" and "one swordfish, no coulis" being shouted out. It was a constant flow and nobody was writing anything down. Somehow or other it all got to the chefs and all the food came out just fine. I was confused just listening!!

Now to the meal. Our server was Jamie and he was excellent. He had wry, almost cynical sense of humor, but he paid good attention to us all evening and I wouldn't hesitate to ask for him again. He also helped Mrs U with her wine selections, giving her several "alternates" apart from the printed wine pairing list. She had decided on the wine pairings for dinner, while I (of course) ordered beer. The beer list has changed a bit since our last visit--they now have Stella, Peroni, Sam Adams, and Newcastle, among others. Since Newcastle is a favorite of mine, Newcastle it was. For appetizers, I had Wood Smoked Muhroom ravioli, with Maderia broth and Serrano Ham. Kathy (er, I mean, mrs Uncleromulus) went wth Gateau of Crab. Both were very good--Mrs U noted hers as "rich and cheesy".
I decided to order an Intermezzo and got the smoked beef Carpaccio. Now of course you're probably wondering why Carpaccio should be smoked. So was I, and when I asked Jamie, the Chef came over to tell me that WDW wouldn't let him serve it raw. So they smoke it lightly, which retains the raw appearance, and gives the meat a bit of a salty taste. It was actually quite good.
Entrees were next and that proved to be a tough call for me. I'm fond of that wonderful veal shank they serve--it's probably their signature dish and has been on the menu ever since we started going to Citricos (which was when it first opened). But the Filet Sicilian also sounded good--and that's when sitting right next to the kitchen came in handy. I got a good look at each one as they were being cooked and served. The shank looked a bit on the small side to me, so I decided on the steak. It was served with Roasted Spanish Onions and Quattro Foromaggi Crushed (i.e. mashed) potatoes. And it had an interesting "shape" as well--not flat, not exactly round--something almost like a Rubics Cube. Mrs U decided on the Crispy Baked breast of Chicken, served with a Sun dried Tomato pasta. I had a bite (of course) and it remided me just a bit of a high quality Chicken Parmigiana. Both entrees were excellent--my steak was cooked perfectly (medium) and was almost fork tender. I have to say tho that at $36.00, it could have been a slightly larger portion---.
Desserts were last and since we were both quite full, we decided on something light--for me, Tropical fruit Creme brulee, and for Mrs. U, the Trio of Sorbet. I'm embarassed to note that I FORGOT to write down which sorbet flavors they had that nite :teeth:. Anyway, the deserts were just right after a somewhat heavy meal and ,once we had our coffee,we were ready to go. The meal lasted nearly a little over an hour and a half, but that was great for us since leisurely is how we prefer to eat.
So all in all--a wonderful meal. It would be nice to know that the crowd there that night was NOT ususual, and maybe at some point they'll be able to open again 7 nights a week. Would be nice to see.
Next up: The Blue Zoo
 
We had been wondering about this place.
Another excellent review...can hardly wait for the Blue Zoo review!
 
Great review! Very informative! I can't wait for the rest of them! But, I"ve got to say that reading on this forum always makes me hungry! Great for the waist line :teeth:
 
Citricos is one of two restaurants - the other being California Grill - that we've not tried (actually, we've eaten at other restaurants in the same locations... Flagler's and Top of the World. Am I dating myself or what?)

We'll check off CG in a couple of weeks, and shoot for Citricos over Thanksgiving. But Citricos really sounds appealing - we'll get there.
 

Thanks for another great review. We have only dined there once...on our first WDW trip as a family (2001) and loved it, so we keep hoping to get back there.
 
Thanks for the review! We have dined at Citrico's at least once a year since it opened ... actually we ate their on its opening night. It is our number 2 restaurant ... with V&A's just edging it out!

Glad to hear it was busy as we would love to see Citrico's open 7 nights a week!
 
Great review! I enjoyed reading it very much - cool that you had such a bird's eye view into the kitchen operation.
 
Mrs. U ordered what I always order.. love it.. thanks for the review of my fave restaurant at WDW...Citrico's..

One more thought to Slapster....how sad that we lost such a great comedian as Mitch Hedburg, way too young to go...what a talent he was..
 
Nice job Uncle R! I always enjoy reading your take on WDW eateries.:earsboy:
 
I loved the review. My mouth is watering - both entrees sound like they were delicious.

I have never dined at Citricos, but I have an ADR there for my 40th bday. I am not really a "foodie", though - those appetizers and extras have me stumped!! I know filet and chicken and creme broulee. :teeth: Hmmmm...... Hope it's not too chichi over the top for me. ;) I just chose Citricos because I love the Grand Floridian and that is where I am staying for my bday trip, so I wanted something on the nicer side instead of the old 1900 PF standby. :)

Thanks for the post! I am looking forward to dining there, even though I will probably not know what most of the menu selection is. (I did try the buffalo steak at Artist Point and LOVED it, so I am open to new things!)

Lives4Disney :goodvibes
 
Uncleromulus, I know I've posted this before, but it is worth saying again; you are an amazing food writer and if you do not do this for a living (or at least put together a book at some point), you've missed your calling in life!

Thanks so much for your amazing review of Citricos--my mouth is just watering and I'm also glad to hear it now has a crowd and a wait for tables. It has been one of me and my DH's favorites--so good we had to go back during our first trip to WDW.

I too, can't wait to read your review of Blue Zoo.

-Laurie
(too long between trips to the world and living vicariously through those lucky enough to go!)
 
I'm glad you had a good exp. We had a fantastic meal there in October and I have been recommending it like crazy but did hear their chef has moved to Narcoosees so I'm afraid I'm telling people to eat at a bad place now! It's nice to know that it passed your test and things are still great.
 
Enjoyed reading your review ~ As always wonderful.
 
Uncleromulus said:
I may now have to revise my usual recommendation as Citricos being a "quiet" place to eat!!

Oh no! I specifically made an ADR in the hope that it would be quiet and fewer kids would be there. :guilty:
 
Well-it usually IS quiet. I asked our server why all the crowd and kids--and he didn't know!!
 
Thanks for the great review. I enjoyed reading it as always. I can't wait to read your Blue Zoo review, especially since we're going to WDW next week. We'll be at Boardwalk Inn and I'm thinking about trying Blue Zoo since it will be close.

What do you think are the most quiet restaurants at WDW?
 
Uncleromulus said:
Well-it usually IS quiet. I asked our server why all the crowd and kids--and he didn't know!!


Oh good, I'll hold out hope that it's just an anomoly :)
 








Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top Bottom