I enjoyed reading your reviews! We were @ WDW 6/15-24 and were at many of the same restaurants!
I definitely agree - be open to trying each restaurant once! This trip we tried several we had never tried before and were pleasantly surprised! Our 1st time at Sci-Fi (glad we didn't let reviews scare us away!); Flame Tree (yum!); Pepper Market (worth trying!); Cape May Character Breakfast (only disappointment was: only 3 characters - Goofy, Minnie, Chip *OR* Dale - ?! But the food was good!!); Rose & Crown Dining Room (lovely!); the re-vamped Garden Grill for dinner (we preferred the old menu, but the new one's not bad and the atmosphere is still great!); LeCellier (yummy, yummy!); Ohana's Feast. That was our biggest surprise! We 3: DH, DD11 and I felt it was our best meal and we're all wondering why we hadn't eaten dinner there before!!
Of course, we had to re-visit some of our favorites - which did not disappoint this trip either! WCC, Biergarten, Crystal Palace & Tusker House!
I think we ate very well this trip!!