Opinions please: waterproof shoe vs breathable?

[Mrs~Incredible]

i know everyone is different, but for those who like a hiking shoe for WDW, do you prefer waterproof or ventilated?

I am torn between the merrel Moab waterproof and the Moab ventilator.

I've used the waterproof ones in Disney before and they worked great, but I am wondering if the ventilated would be even more comfy? I do tend to get "hot feet", lol.

It will be hot- we are going in May.

But I know it rains often, and who wants wet feet?

Hmmmm hot and dry or cool and wet?

What are your thoughts?

Thanks!!

 

[Lisa loves Pooh]

I prefer ventilated. I also have hot feet.

I wear Keens though. I forget which one, but it is like a closed toed sandal for hiking. Ventilated AND it can get wet.

 

[heidijanesmith]

I have 'hot feet" too. Even though I have not tried those particular shoes, I like ventilated shoes. I would rather have wet sandals/flip flops then non-vent shoes. We tour with Reef flip flops, which I have never toured in flip flops before, but these are the best supportive-nonblister-nonaching shoes for us when it's hot and we have to walk long distances.

 

[RatherB@Disney]

I've worn the Merrell Siren Sport with GoreTex, and they did keep my feet nice and dry during wet days at the parks; however, like a previous poster, tend to prefer Keen Whisper sandals. The sandals protect the toes and are quick-drying. They are the most comfortable during hot & wet weather.

 

[PeasandCarrots]

Since you are going in May I would definitely go the ventilated route. I always take 2 pairs so if one gets soaked I can wear the second the next day while the first dries. If you were going in cooler weather I'd say waterproof.

 

[StormyCA]

I usually wear flip flops, but if I do wear shoes, I carry spare socks (Smartwool 'Hide and Seek') and a pair of super light weight flip-flops in my backpack. Even waterproof shoes can get water inside them on water rides. I usually put on the flips for water rides or change out the socks if they get wet.

 

[slaveone]

I like the ventilated hiker and I carry a pair of extra socks in hot weather. In cool weather I go with waterproof but still extra socks or liners. Somedays I feel like a trip to disney is like planning a hike on the AT but with less chance of bear attacks.