I think Shutters is probably the most un talked about restaurant on the dis! We really enjoyed our meal there in December. I had the prime rib which was amazing (I am surprised I ordered it because I usually find it sort of blah, but this was so good). We all four enjoyed our meal and the service was wonderful. We were staying at CBR and we had one ts left and we ended up cancelling it to go back to our resort before the long flight home the next day. It ended up being so much better than I thought. The atmpshere is pretty standard, but found the food to be excellent.
Dh and I were talking tonight and saying we might eat there in October, we aren't staying at CBR but enjoy the resort and this restaurant. To us, it was good enough to warrant a separate trip over. For sure when we return to CBR in June, we'll eat there.
For the record I enjoy Maya Grill as well, another moderate resort full service restaurant that doesn't get a lot of mention around here. Although I liked Shutters better.