Opinions on Port Orleans, Carribean Beach or Coronado Springs

theheartonfire03

The Lost Boys
Joined
Jan 14, 2015
Messages
66
Hi!

Planning a trip, but can't decide between Port Orleans, Caribbean Beach Resort or Coronado Springs, so I'm asking for opinions on which ones you'd choose?

Thanks! :)

EDIT: Party of Four adults.
 
CSR or POR would be our favorite moderates.

CSR has the edge for us but they both have lots of perks that we enjoy.
 
You didn't indicate family size, type of vacation experience, theming, spending more time at the resort, etc.

Kinda hard to make a recommendation when you don't know the parameters to begin with.

I have been to all three, but mostly as a solo guest, so my opinions may be different than what you are looking for.
 
We've stayed at Por, PoFQ, and CS. CBR us next. Between Por and CS, Por hands down is the winner (and we stayed in the executive suite at CS so that should have some meaning).
 
I love Port Orleans French Quarter. But it doesn't have its own table service restaurant. Don't know if that's important to you. It's small, intimate feeling, and has a great design.
 
Four adults in one room? Or two rooms at the same resort?

I like CS very much, for some reason some people do not (?) but I think it is beautiful. I have friends who stayed in the business rooms there, (not on business) and it is almost like having a concierge room at a Deluxe. Nice option, esp. if you are putting 4 adults in one room. I love walking the grounds after dark there, and the pool is very nice too. Huge hot tub.

I am staying at POFQ for a couple of nights in April, can't wait, I last stayed there 10 years ago. CB is ok but some areas are very far from the main buildings. People say that about CS, but there you can sometimes cut thru the middle of the resort. (the buildings are spread out in a different shape if that makes any sense).

Never stayed at Riverside yet.
 
We are big Port Orleans fans, especially if it's all adults. POFQ is our favourite resort of all. The boat to DTD opens up more table service restaurants (Raglan Road, House of Blues...) and incredible quick service meals (our favourite Wolfgang Puck Express). Also, there is a huge Disney Store in DTD if you are interested in some shopping. The boat ride to DTD is about 15 min from POFQ and is relaxing / pleasant. :thumbsup2
 
I have visited all three resorts but only ever stayed at POR.

What I like about POR
there are advantages of staying at POR which the others don't include - boats from the resort to downtown, POFQ is only a short walk away, there is a bike hire & horse drawn carriage rides around the resort.

Also in POR the rooms are split into 3 different themes, there is the rustic wooded area of the Bayou which also have the choice of bigger rooms, the romantic anti-bellum mansions & the new Royal rooms which are more Disney character themed (also in the mansion area).

I've enjoyed visiting the other two resorts over the years. I love the theming of Caribbean Beach but in my opinion the resort is too spread out & it really comes down to which Island area your room is located (& how far it is to the amenities of the resort hub), but Caribbean has lovely beaches. Coronado Springs is the newest of the 3, but can sometimes become very busy as it is used as a convention resort - Pepper Market is probably the best counter service of all three resorts though.

All the resorts have lovely walks & in all three there are lots of different wildlife to see (CB has turtles/terrapins to feed, I have also seen armadillo's & otters from POR). As if you have a particular park you want to be nearer too, both CB & POR are nearest to Epcot while CS is in the Animal Kingdom area, hope this helps :thumbsup2:
 
I haven't stayed at the CS so I can't offer an opinion on that one but I loved the POR and the CBR. Don't be too put off by how spread out the CBR is (unless you have mobility issues) as the walks are very scenic and normally 10 mins max.
We stayed at the POR last year and were very impressed, the boat to Dowtown is especially useful. The atmosphere is really good and they have a good bar with a very funny show, which would probably appeal to a group of adults.
From my experience, you won't be let down by either the POR or CBR but if I was forced to pick, I would go for POR.
 
I would never put four adults in one room. That's not a vacation to me.

If you mean two rooms with two people each, what parks do you prefer? That may impact your decision.
 
Another POR fan here. Stayed fall break 2013 and it was lovely. We loved the theming and the kids adored the pool. Never ate at Boatwrights but did eat at the quick service for breakfast and it was fine. Boat to DTD is a great feature.

Headed back for spring break. Originally booked at CBR but called a few weeks ago and switched to POFQ :). Looking forward to enjoying the benefit of two resorts that week!
 
I have stayed at all of the moderate resorts (including both POR and POFQ) If you have young or middle grade children I would go for POR. If it is more of a grown up trip the edge for me would be POFQ or CS. Caribbean Beach resort just seemed to hectic to me. Also, I preferred the themes at the other moderates. Enjoy. I do think the moderates are the best deal going. Beachfan
 
We've stayed at CBR and POR. I was not a fan of CBR, but it was a while ago, and my daughter was a toddler. We did not like the food court-it might be better now. We did like the big pool, and we came home with some beautiful pictures throughout the resort. Great flowers! I have no desire to go back, though, it just felt big and crowded everywhere from check in to the pool to the food court.

POR was wonderful. Beautiful and shady and relaxing. The pool and pool bar was really fun. We stayed in Parterre Place and took some gorgeous pictures. Supposedly, that is one of the farthest locations from the food court and pool but it was okay with us. By this trip my daughter was out of her stroller and more independent, so maybe that made the whole trip more enjoyable. But we just loved it. Extra points because you can take that little boat over to DTD. Or walk over to POFQ and try their food court. I would absolutely go back there.
 
We've stayed at CBR and POR and have visited CSR.

Our choice would absolutely be POR.

For us, CBR felt a little dated and we didn't particularly care for the food court. The pool was okay, but better suited for younger kids and the size of the resort was quite inconvenient.

On the other hand, we felt POR to feel very relaxed, well-themed and just had that "Disney" feel. We stayed in the Mansions section and our room was quite central to food court, pool and buses. Plus, we loved the extras like the bike rentals and the boat to DTD.

We have visited CSR to eat just to see if it would appeal to us and I think we just prefer the theming and dining at POR.

I know POR is loved by many on the DIS and I really don't think you can go wrong there!
 
Have stayed at POR 2x and stayed at CBR for the first time in November. We would have booked POR again but it was during free dining and that resort was excluded.

CBR is a beautiful resort. The landscaping is gorgeous and the new rooms are really pretty. But it really is a HUGe resort and so spread out. We don't mind walking but are accustomed to at least not walking forever to get to the food court. They should really have more walking bridges that go across the lake - that would help immensely. We even had a preferred room, but it was preferred because it was close to a quiet pool and not close to the food court. And there was just something that didn't feel like "home" to us, which is how we've felt at POR. Also, wasn't super keen on having check in and the food court on opposite sides of the resort. It was kind of odd.

POR we absolutely love. It's a large resort also, but not quite as spread out. It feels so comfortable to us. They also have the boat that goes to DTD, which is a nice plus. We had a preferred location on our first trip, which was just off the bridge to the island. It was a GREAT location because we were so close to everything. On our 2nd trip we booked a Royal Room and enjoyed the room but it was a lot further out. We would forego the RR in the future and book a preferred location instead. POR does feel like "home" to us. It's just a great place. :)
 
I say look at lots of pictures and go with whatever theme appeals to you. There isn't a huge difference between them other than the themes (and POFQ's size if that one is in the running, though you didn't mention it).

I have stayed at POR twice (king room and royal room) and it's just okay, IMO. I don't love it.

I stayed at CBR once and liked it much better than POR. I liked the bright colors and the boats on the lake. I liked the music and the pool area better than POR.

I stayed at POFQ once and liked it. I would go back. The small size was nice and the grounds were charming. I prefer CBR though.

I have not stayed at CSR...yet. My 12 year old was there last year with a friend's family and she said it is her favorite of the moderates, but she is 12 lol. The pool was a big draw for her, and they stayed business level which gave them access to a lounge with breakfast and snacks. She loved that. (We never stay club level anywhere.) She also said the buses were never crowded and Pepper Market was great. She wants me to put it on our "short list" for an upcoming trip in the near future. The decor really doesn't appeal to me, but I'm willing to give it a try.
 
It really depends on what you're looking for, especially being four adults. I haven't personally stayed at POR/FQ, and it's been over a decade since we were at CBR, so I can't offer much information there.

We've stayed at CSR several times and it can have a bit more of a "mature" atmosphere thanks to the convention center. There are several bars and lounges (One at the pool, another lakeside, and a third in the main lobby building). The quiet pools are really nice, they have a large hot tub at the main pool area, along with a health center (I believe they offer some minor spa amenities there) in the Casitas section.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom