opinions on dinner choices please!

[Blueeyes101817]

Most trips, i dont pick and choose places and make reservations for dinner--we usually just do spur of the moment..
well this trip, we have the myw Dining and we sat down today and decided on where to eat..we chose 2 character meals and 2 regular..just wanted to get opinions..

we are eating at--
Cinderellas Gala Feast
Mama Melrose
Garden Grill
and the italian restaurant in italy

thanks for any input!

 

[headoflife]

We are also doing 1900 Park Faire and Alfredos. I have heard mixed things about Garden Grill, so we decided to skip it. My only concerna would be that you are doing only two regular sit down meals, and they are both Italian food and that two of your choices are at Epcot. Have fun!

 

[Blueeyes101817]

hmm i didnt even think about 2 being at epcot..
as with the italian, i am a very picky eater, so we had to stick with italian for the big dinners---we want to be able to get the most out of this dining plan!

thanks!!

 

[nukeantz]

I LOVE Italian food. Mamma Melrose is great but Alfredos is awful. I know everyone has different opinions about restaurants and food , but have not seen many good reviews at all for this restaurant.

 

[Blueeyes101817]

really? hmmm thanks!

 

[3lilprincesses]

i think it was just last week that i read a good review oa alfredos. i say if you want to try it, try it . . . and then come back and give US a review!!

 

[CamColt]

We have eaten at Mama Melrose 8 trips in a row, with our 9th coming up this weekend. Obviously we like it a lot!

As for Alfredos, I havent eaten there in 10 years, but I know we enjoyed our meal there. We just havent made it back (I would like to though). A couple years ago we went to WDW with our friends and they went to lunch at Alfredos one day. They loved it.

I agree with 3lilprincesses' way of thinking. If you think something appeals to you, you should try it. I know I enjoy some of the worst reviewed restuarants and I havent like some of the best reviews ones.

 

[housecat]

If you're looking for a second Italian restaurant that is not in Epcot, you could try Tony's Town Square in MK. I haven't been to Tony's or Alfredo's personally, but I've heard mixed reviews about both. May be another option for you...

 

[BluOrchid2]

LOL - I was just going to say, "At least you didn't choose Tony's Town Square for your Italian!" (boo, hiss on Tony's)

Liberty Tree Tavern in the MK, O'Hana for breakfast OR dinner, and Crystal Palace breakfast are some of our favorites. We are trying Cinderella's Gala Feast for the first time in September, too.