They used to give more but now all used toys have to be lead tested.
Generally, I do a four step process. I have a one day yard sale (can you do it at someone else's house?) I advertise in the paper with others. Full price till noon, then I'll barter. At 3:00 p.m. I pack up everything & take to Once Upon a Child. They dig through it & reject 3/4. Then I let my friends dig through it. Then I donate the leftovers to Goodwill. I spend 4 days doing this & only do it every 2-3 years when I have a lot of nice stuff (I have a giant basement so I can keep stuff a long time.) I've made as much as $700.00 with this process and as little as $75.00.
I would make only a fraction of that if I had just taken it to Once Upon a Child to begin with.
So it's up to you. I always figure it by how much I'll make per hour to see if it's worth it. If I think I can have a $300.00 yard sale & make $75.00 at Once Upon a Child, it's worth it to me. If I don't, I just donate to Goodwill to get it out of my house and into someone's who needs it.