Olivia's Old Key West

[bonnie w]

I was wondering if anyone has eaten either lunch or dinner here. I would appreciate your opinion & also any food recommendations.

 

[Dogslider]

We haven't eaten there, but will wait with you for some replies as we are staying at OKW on our next trip. Which as you can see is quite a long way off! But I love to think about it.

Pam

 

[Eric Julie and Hailey]

We're DVCers who have eaten at Olivia's a couple of times. It is very good -- but, it is also pricey. I would rate it a "C" for value and "B" for food. It is not a restaurant for which I would go out of the way -- but, it is a good choice if you are staying at OKW.

 

[Uncleromulus]

We do lunch there on occasion--the prime Rib Sandwich is great, as is the veggie Wrap. Service is always good.
By the way--they have excellent breakfast's too.

 

[mitros]

It's pretty good,a lot of basics,chicken, burgers,crabcakes,etc. It is not as pricey as a whole lot of other restaurants at the world, but it is not cheap. I'd have to say the prices are sort of in between. Lunch is less expensive, and they do have a great breakfast including eggs benedict if you like that sort of thing

 

[Deb & Bill]

Olivia's is great for a later night dinner or early for breakfast. We have also eaten lunch there while we were waiting to check in. OKW is our home, so we eat there at least once on every trip. My husband loves to get up early and have a cup of coffee or eat breakfast there.

 

[hercamore]

We stayed at OKW Jan 2-8. Ate at Olivias one night, and I have to tell you we had the worst service there.

Unbeliievablyy slow service, food was good tho. Very pricy.

We didn't go back.

Herc.

 

[ahutton]

We've been for lunch and dinner, and both were good meals and reasonable. The Prime Rib sandwich is excellent, so was the Cuban Pork sandwich. The burger gets very high marks too, not at all like what was being served at the fast food counters.

 

[disboo]

We ate at Olivia's in November (3 adults, 2 17 year old boys) and we all found something to enjoy. Most of us had the fish special of the night - I forget which fish, but it was delicious. The ambience is southern beach house, it is quiet,and the service was attentive. We really enjoyed it as a "medium" type dinner - not a big splurge like Jiko or Artist Point, but not as expensive either. Although, as you know, nothing is inexpensive in the World. We intend to return!

 

[madcoco]

We enjoy eating there. If you are a DVC member or AP holder or DC member.(can't never keep those discounts straight.Who remembers which one? LOL )you can get a % off your check or a free glass of house wine or smoothie(key lime! ) with each entree purchase.

 

[atlanta braves fan]

I ate there for lunch and dinner back in December. Had a burger for lunch and it was very good and filling. Had the dolphin for dinner and it was also very good. Service was a bit slow , but it wasn't terrible. The shrimp fritters were great. The beef vegetable soup was good. If you happen to eat breakfast there and order French toast, definitely try the pineapple jelly. I am still trying to find some to use at home....

 

[CHIPSTER]

Ate at Olivia's for the first time this past December and can't wait to go back. We weren't rushed at dinner and they have a nice variety on the menu. 2 of us had the petite filet/lobster stuffed shrimp, 2 had prime rib (huge portion for the small cut) and 1 had grilled snapper with mango butter. We all loved our meals. Cato was our waiter and he was excellent. Too bad we went to Olivia's toward the end of our trip or we would have definitely gone back the same week.

 

[LisaR]

We just ate there last week for the first time in a long time. Excellent server. He was really nice, funny and quick. Very good food. Very tasty. I thought it was very expensive, though. However, we would eat there again.

Lisa