We also booked at H&V for the FP. I really wanted Brown Derby, but mom didn't see anything she liked on their menu, and Melrose, dad couldn't see paying that much for Italian.

So Hollywood it is. My husband is a die-hard buffet hater, mostly because he grew up enduring golden corral and its ilk. I keep telling him though, that a resort/WDW buffet is a lot different! Hope it holds true for H&V!
My view is, I'm in WDW for a limited time. I can put up with 1 so-so meal in order to save myself 2 hours of waiting around for a show, even if it's a show awesome enough to warrant the wait. As long as H&V is toleravle enough to give us fuel to make it through the rest of the evening until we get back to our resort, I'll be happy.
I'll be saving my high expectations for Jiko, Boma, Biergarten, Sci-fi, etc!

Oh man, it's getting closer and closer and I can't wait!