This was our dilemma, too. We have been to both, although not either one for a while now. Originally, I booked 'Ohana, but then I kept thinking about some of our not so great experiences there. We loved 'Ohana long ago when the menu was a bit different. We have tried it since the change (although not the noodle change) and were not all that pleased with it. However, we thought we might try once more. But, we are going over the July 4th holiday which means the surcharge will be in place. In the end, we switched to Kona because we have never had a bad meal there, and if 'Ohana disappointed then I'd be really upset for having spent that much money.