Imzadi
♥ Saved by an angel in a trench coat!
- Joined
- Oct 29, 2004
- Messages
- 41,262
i feel there is a certain risk of things getting wet when brought to the pool area. NO the child should NOT have touched his things, but if it was something that could not get wet maybe you should leave it in the room or at least in a ziploc bag.
There is a REASONABILITY of risk that I think a court takes into account. Then man DID wrap up his items to protect from reasonable amount of pool-side splashing. He also wrapped them to hide from view, so a pickpocket couldn't just casually walk by and pick up the items without rummaging through the towel. It is UNreasonable to have to pre-think and plan for every known scenario.
Even if a thief just ran through the area, grabbed the towel with the items, and the police later caught him, the thief would still be held accountable for the items or the price of the items if they were ruined.
Why wouldn't this be true of the parents of the child? It doesn't matter if the child did it intentionally or not.
i think a lot of people try to shirk out of responsibility because some people spend way to much on frivalous things, like $600-1000 wallets. i'm sorry i wouldn't volontarily pay for that, take me to court. if you can afford it the 1st time then buy yourself another.
i would offer to replace the phone.
So, you hit Donald Trump's Mercedes, and because he can afford to pay for it the first time, you shouldn't be responsible to pay?
I guarantee you, you break something of Trump's he will expect you to pay. Just because YOU can't afford to pay doesn't absolve you of the responsibility to pay. If that were the case, every burglar caught in the act of stealing, could just break the item, and claim they can't pay for it, but the owner obviously can.
Richer people aren't responsible for your (general you) lack of money.

). 
