Oh My Goodness. Just Witnessed Something CRAZY! WWYD?

i feel there is a certain risk of things getting wet when brought to the pool area. NO the child should NOT have touched his things, but if it was something that could not get wet maybe you should leave it in the room or at least in a ziploc bag.

There is a REASONABILITY of risk that I think a court takes into account. Then man DID wrap up his items to protect from reasonable amount of pool-side splashing. He also wrapped them to hide from view, so a pickpocket couldn't just casually walk by and pick up the items without rummaging through the towel. It is UNreasonable to have to pre-think and plan for every known scenario.

Even if a thief just ran through the area, grabbed the towel with the items, and the police later caught him, the thief would still be held accountable for the items or the price of the items if they were ruined.

Why wouldn't this be true of the parents of the child? It doesn't matter if the child did it intentionally or not.


i think a lot of people try to shirk out of responsibility because some people spend way to much on frivalous things, like $600-1000 wallets. i'm sorry i wouldn't volontarily pay for that, take me to court. if you can afford it the 1st time then buy yourself another.
i would offer to replace the phone.

So, you hit Donald Trump's Mercedes, and because he can afford to pay for it the first time, you shouldn't be responsible to pay? :rolleyes: I guarantee you, you break something of Trump's he will expect you to pay.

Just because YOU can't afford to pay doesn't absolve you of the responsibility to pay. If that were the case, every burglar caught in the act of stealing, could just break the item, and claim they can't pay for it, but the owner obviously can. :rolleyes: Richer people aren't responsible for your (general you) lack of money.
 
So if my kid accidentally threw your stuff in the pool and I was extremely apologetic and offered to replave the items you would scream like a nut?

I love it when those that caused the problems try to convince them self and the whole world the victims did it all to them self. :lmao:
Like in :"if you hadn't opened a store I would not have robbed you. It is you own fault". :rotfl2:

But I have to get some sleep,it waaaaaaaaaaay past midnight and tomorrow I have to raise with the roosters and earn money so strangers can throw it in the pool.
1.gif

See you all tomorrow but I bet this topic is closed by then. Goodnight.
11.gif
 
I love it when those that caused the problems try to convince them self and the whole world the victims did it all to them self. :lmao:
Like in :"if you hadn't opened a store I would not have robbed you. It is you own fault". :rotfl2:

But I have to get some sleep,it waaaaaaaaaaay past midnight and tomorrow I have to raise with the roosters and earn money so strangers can throw it in the pool.
1.gif

See you all tomorrow but I bet this topic is closed by then. Goodnight.
11.gif


That's not what she said.


KTHXBAI!
 
I think they should pay whatever it costs to replace his wallet which could be considerably higher. My wallet was $600, so $20 wouldn't come close. The chlorine would ruin it, so yes I would expect them to pay to replace it.


Ain't gonna happen...nobody's gonna reimburse you that much...a $600 wallet falls under the category of "shoulda left it in your room" or some other safe place. $20 seems like a good offer here. Too bad for your $600 wallet if you leave it laying around.

Jim
 
So, you hit Donald Trump's Mercedes, and because he can afford to pay for it the first time, you shouldn't be responsible to pay? :rolleyes: I guarantee you, you break something of Trump's he will expect you to pay.

Just because YOU can't afford to pay doesn't absolve you of the responsibility to pay. If that were the case, every burglar caught in the act of stealing, could just break the item, and claim they can't pay for it, but the owner obviously can. :rolleyes: Richer people aren't responsible for your (general you) lack of money.

OK you are trying to compare an auto accident with a burglary. REALLY!!
i believe a person is responsible for what is REASONABLE, and i'm sure Donald Trump probably has insurance to cover his car, because i doubt many people have the insurance coverage for a mercedes that trump drives. i believe that when you decide to carry or drive something that is extravagantly more expensive then is common, don't expect the average person(general us) to replace it.
 
OK you are trying to compare an auto accident with a burglary. REALLY!!
i believe a person is responsible for what is REASONABLE, and i'm sure Donald Trump probably has insurance to cover his car, because i doubt many people have the insurance coverage for a mercedes that trump drives. i believe that when you decide to carry or drive something that is extravagantly more expensive then is common, don't expect the average person(general us) to replace it.

Whether accident or burglary, the point is when someone breaks or steals something of someone else's they are responsible for paying for it. I'm sure the courts wouldn't agree with you. That's why they make payment plans, deduct money from wages or bank accounts long term. etc., until the debt is paid. You don't just pay what you can and call it a day. You pay what the item is worth. It doesn't matter how much money the owner has.
 
Whether accident or burglary, the point is when someone breaks or steals something of someone else's they are responsible for paying for it. I'm sure the courts wouldn't agree with you. That's why they make payment plans, deduct money from wages or bank accounts long term. etc., until the debt is paid. You don't just pay what you can and call it a day. You pay what the item is worth. It doesn't matter how much money the owner has.

I agree. That is what insurance is for (I work in insurance ;)).

What I'm thinking right now is where did it say in the original post that it was an expensive wallet? All this man might want is his cellphone replaced. If he is a businessman, his cellphone could be his lifeline and that is why he freaked out (not saying that was justified).
 
Is there a limit to this theory that people should pay regardless of the cost of the item?

What if I decide to bring my priceless Ming vase to my son's soccer game for my dog to drink out of, and some cheering parent steps on it? What if I send my da Vinci etching to school with my Kindergartener for show and tell and another child decides to color it in with sharpies? Should I be able to lay claim to their house as partial payment?

At some point, I think the person with the super expensive item needs to either cough up for insurance, or think carefully about the settings into which they take their item. I'm not sure this is an example, since for all we know the guy was responsible and took everything but his room key and $10 out of his wallet, but I do think there needs to be a line.

I'm pretty sure Trump agrees with me and has decent insurance coverage.
 
Whether accident or burglary, the point is when someone breaks or steals something of someone else's they are responsible for paying for it.
i'm sorry but i don't think anyone walks into the pool area with a reasonable expectations of replacing a $600-1000 wallet that was laying around.
Debbie B - the expensive wallet is more of a hypothetical discussion, as far as i read no-one said that he had any expensive items.
 
It's not that we refuse to take responsibility I am not liking the idea of taking full responsibility. If he left his stuff in his room this never would have happened, either It was a bad series of events- poor decision to leave valuables unattended near a pool, a two year old walks by and chucks the stuff in the pool. He isn't exempt from blame, he left his valuables unattended on a pool chair where it could have been damaged or stolen. So I will pay part but all...I don't know. I would be tempted to do the small claims court no matter what, to see what the judge decides is our percentage of responsibility. I know it won't be 100%. I will reiterate that I feel bad, but I am not in the position to be forking over a (possible) thousand dollar check just like that.

A man was standing at a crosswalk waiting for the traffic light to change to green. When the light changed, he started across the street.

Another man was driving drunk and speeding down the same street and hit the man crossing the street.

In my mind the guy crossing the street was the innocent victim.

Some people here would think the guy crossing the street is at fault too because (1) he should not have been in the street in the first place, and (2) he should have anticipated that maybe a drunk driver in a speeding car might hit him. :rotfl2:
 
Here is from Wikipedia about Damages. There may be a better one, as I am NOT a lawyer, and this law example doesn't deal with broken goods, exactly.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damages

Damages

(My bolding & underlining.)

In law, damages is an award of money to be paid to, a person as compensation for loss or injury. . . []

Compensatory damages, also called actual damages, are paid to compensate the claimant for loss, injury, or harm suffered by (see requirement of causation) another's breach of duty. . . []

Quantum/measure of damages:
On a breach of contract by a defendant, a court generally awards the sum that would restore the injured party to the economic position they expected from performance of the promise or promises (known as an "expectation measure" or "benefit-of-the-bargain" measure of damages).

When it is either not possible or not desirable to award damages measured in that way, a court may award money damages designed to restore the injured party to the economic position they occupied at the time the contract was entered (known as the "reliance measure"), or designed to prevent the breaching party from being unjustly enriched ("restitution")

People don't just get to pay what they can/can't afford. :rolleyes: Otherwise, all "poor" people would essentially be getting a Get Out of Jail Free card.
 
A man was standing at a crosswalk waiting for the traffic light to change to green. When the light changed, he started across the street.

Another man was driving drunk and speeding down the same street and hit the man crossing the street.

In my mind the guy crossing the street was the innocent victim.

Some people here would think the guy crossing the street is at fault too because (1) he should not have been in the street in the first place, and (2) he should have anticipated that maybe a drunk driver in a speeding car might hit him. :rotfl2:

And if he was a neuro9surgeon making 250,000 a year the person hitting him thinks that is too much to pay him so his family should only be compensated as if he made 50,000 because that is what they think is reasonable !!!!
 
i'm sorry but i don't think anyone walks into the pool area with a reasonable expectations of replacing a $600-1000 wallet that was laying around.
DEbbie B - the expensive wallet is more of a hypothetical discussion, as far as i read no-one said that he had any expensive items.

It's a risky world out there!
It isn't about the reasonable expectation of the person breaking the item. See the Wikipedia quote I quoted above. You break it, you pay for it.


I'm done. :wave2:
 
And if he was a neuro9surgeon making 250,000 a year the person hitting him thinks that is too much to pay him so his family should only be compensated as if he made 50,000 because that is what they think is reasonable !!!!
again there is a difference between criminal acts such as drunk driving and a 2yr old accidentally throwing a persons belongings in the pool.
but what do you do if they simply don't make 250,000 a year to pay you? i don't think a court is going to force the guilty person into slavery. this is what i am saying about reasonable expectations.
now i would pay a reasonable amount on the spot if this was my child but if the bill became extravagant like a $1000 wallet, i would go to court.
Imzadi- you are right it is a very risky world out their.
 
It's a risky world out there!
It isn't about the reasonable expectation of the person breaking the item. See the Wikipedia quote I quoted above. You break it, you pay for it.


I'm done. :wave2:

That quote was for when damages are awarded. I am wondering about the legality of making the parents of a 2 year old replace belongings that were left unattended. I googled myself, and I did not find a precident for an accident..I found some for arson, malicious intent, etc, but even those damages were capped. A lot of what this thread goes into is what the posters would do ethically, but ethically doesn't matter it's what their legal obligation is what the big difference is.

The instances of the car accidents, hit and runs, drunk drivers, Bill Gates' mercedes or the neurosurgeon's pay are all irrevelent, it's whether a parent is LEGALLY responsible for a child's mistake?
 
again there is a difference between criminal acts such as drunk driving and a 2yr old accidentally throwing a persons belongings in the pool.
but what do you do if they simply don't make 250,000 a year to pay you? i don't think a court is going to force the guilty person into slavery. this is what i am saying about reasonable expectations.
now i would pay a reasonable amount on the spot if this was my child but if the bill became extravagant like a $1000 wallet, i would go to court.

I noticed that, as well. You can't get blood out of a turnip. Good luck getting your $250,000 out of (hypothetical) poverty level salary. You may get a judgement but you may never see a dime.
 
That quote was for when damages are awarded. I am wondering about the legality of making the parents of a 2 year old replace belongings that were left unattended. I googled myself, and I did not find a precident for an accident..I found some for arson, malicious intent, etc, but even those damages were capped. A lot of what this thread goes into is what the posters would do ethically, but ethically doesn't matter it's what their legal obligation is what the big difference is.

The instances of the car accidents, hit and runs, drunk drivers, Bill Gates' mercedes or the neurosurgeon's pay are all irrevelent, it's whether a parent is LEGALLY responsible for a child's mistake?

As far as I know yes parents are responsible for their childrens actions.

Also an accident would be the child was falling and hit the table on the way down and the phone fell into the pool, grabbing the phone and or towel and throwing it into the water isn't an accident.

I love how this has become an accident instead of a child being naughty and parents not stopping them.
 
The parents are 100% responsible for 100% of the man's losses. They should immediately pony up the money and offer apologies for their son's actions. If they don't take 100% responsiblity and only want to pay half or some lesser amount as I've seen other posts suggest they would offer then the man should take them to court.
Calling the police was wise IMHO because it makes sure they do pay up or have documention of the incident for court purposes.
And it sounds like this guy totally overreacted. He should not have been yelling at anyone over it.
 
And if he was a neuro9surgeon making 250,000 a year the person hitting him thinks that is too much to pay him so his family should only be compensated as if he made 50,000 because that is what they think is reasonable !!!!

Perhaps the earlier example of the drowning man whose family was unhappy that he was fished out of the water....could be the same guy and the family of the dead man might give the drunk driver a reward. :laughing:
 
I love it when those that caused the problems try to convince them self and the whole world the victims did it all to them self. :lmao:
Like in :"if you hadn't opened a store I would not have robbed you. It is you own fault". :rotfl2:

But I have to get some sleep,it waaaaaaaaaaay past midnight and tomorrow I have to raise with the roosters and earn money so strangers can throw it in the pool.
1.gif

See you all tomorrow but I bet this topic is closed by then. Goodnight.
11.gif

How does apologizing and offering to replace your items make me a victim? If I do all that and you continue to scream like a nut then I guess I am a victim. A victim of a nutty person who needs some anger management classes and/or an evaluation by professionals.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom